Fernández-de-Las-Peñas César, Cancela-Cilleruelo Ignacio, Rodríguez-Jiménez Jorge, Fuensalida-Novo Stella, Martín-Guerrero José D, Pellicer-Valero Oscar J, de-la-Llave-Rincón Ana I
Department of Physical Therapy, Occupational Therapy, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, 28922 Madrid, Spain.
Intelligent Data Analysis Laboratory, Department of Electronic Engineering, ETSE (Engineering School), Universitat de València (UV), 46100 Valencia, Spain.
Biomedicines. 2023 Jun 29;11(7):1863. doi: 10.3390/biomedicines11071863.
Fatigue and dyspnoea are common post-COVID symptoms. The aim of this study was to apply Sankey plots and exponential bar plots for visualizing the evolution and trajectory of post-COVID fatigue and dyspnoea symptoms in a cohort of previously hospitalized COVID-19 survivors. A total of 1266 previously hospitalized patients due to COVID-19 participated in this multicentre study. They were assessed at hospital admission (T0), 8.4 months (T1), 13.2 months (T2) and 18.3 months (T3) after hospital discharge and were asked about the presence of self-reported fatigue or dyspnoea symptoms. Fatigue was defined as a self-perceived feeling of constant tiredness and/or weakness whereas dyspnoea was defined as a self-perceived feeling of shortness of breath at rest. We specifically asked for fatigue and dyspnoea that participants attributed to the infection. Clinical/hospitalization data were collected from hospital medical records. The prevalence of post-COVID fatigue was 56.94% ( = 721) at T1, 52.31% ( = 662) at T2 and 42.66% ( = 540) at T3. The prevalence of dyspnoea at rest decreased from 28.71% ( = 363) at hospital admission (T0), to 21.29% ( = 270) at T1, to 13.96% ( = 177) at T2 and 12.04% ( = 153) at T3. The Sankey plots revealed that 469 (37.08%) and 153 (12.04%) patients exhibited fatigue and dyspnoea at all follow-up periods. The recovery exponential curves show a decreased prevalence trend, showing that fatigue and dyspnoea recover the following three years after hospitalization. The regression models revealed that the female sex and experiencing the symptoms (e.g., fatigue, dyspnoea) at T1 were factors associated with the presence of post-COVID fatigue or dyspnoea at T2 and T3. The use of Sankey plots shows a fluctuating evolution of post-COVID fatigue and dyspnoea during the first two years after infection. In addition, exponential bar plots revealed a decreased prevalence of these symptoms during the first years after. The female sex is a risk factor for the development of post-COVID fatigue and dyspnoea.
疲劳和呼吸困难是新冠康复后的常见症状。本研究旨在应用桑基图和指数条形图,以可视化一组曾住院治疗的新冠病毒感染者康复后疲劳和呼吸困难症状的演变及发展轨迹。共有1266名曾因新冠病毒感染住院的患者参与了这项多中心研究。在出院后的入院时(T0)、8.4个月(T1)、13.2个月(T2)和18.3个月(T3)对他们进行评估,并询问他们是否存在自我报告的疲劳或呼吸困难症状。疲劳被定义为一种持续疲倦和/或虚弱的自我感觉,而呼吸困难被定义为休息时自我感觉到的呼吸急促。我们特别询问了参与者归因于感染的疲劳和呼吸困难情况。临床/住院数据从医院病历中收集。新冠康复后疲劳的患病率在T1时为56.94%(n = 721),T2时为52.31%(n = 662),T3时为42.66%(n = 540)。静息时呼吸困难的患病率从入院时(T0)的28.71%(n = 363)降至T1时的21.29%(n = 270),T2时的13.96%(n = 177),T3时的12.04%(n = 153)。桑基图显示,469名(37.08%)和153名(12.04%)患者在所有随访期均出现疲劳和呼吸困难。恢复指数曲线显示患病率呈下降趋势,表明疲劳和呼吸困难在住院后的三年内有所恢复。回归模型显示,女性以及在T1时出现症状(如疲劳、呼吸困难)是与T2和T3时存在新冠康复后疲劳或呼吸困难相关的因素。使用桑基图显示了感染后前两年新冠康复后疲劳和呼吸困难的波动演变。此外,指数条形图显示这些症状在最初几年患病率下降。女性是新冠康复后疲劳和呼吸困难发生的一个风险因素。