Picelli Serena, Danielis Matteo, Zanotti Renzo
Laboratory of Studies and Evidence Based Nursing, Department of Medicine, University of Padua, 35131 Padova, Italy.
Vaccines (Basel). 2023 Jul 14;11(7):1239. doi: 10.3390/vaccines11071239.
In Italy, from April 2021, healthcare workers were required to receive the COVID-19 vaccine; if they refused it, an immediate unpaid suspension was implemented until they received the vaccine. Although there are numerous quantitative studies on the factors that influenced vaccine hesitancy during the COVID-19 pandemic, qualitative research on the causes of vaccine refusal is still missing. This research aimed to investigate the phenomenon of nurses who refused to receive COVID-19 vaccination despite being required to do so, as well as the reasons behind their refusal. Furthermore, the actions of those who abandoned this stance were explored. This was a qualitative study involving the methodological approach of grounded theory. Twenty-four nurses were interviewed virtually via Zoom from May to July 2022. Anti-vax behavior-as emerged from nurses' experiences-was based on seven themes: (1) job satisfaction, (2) the main sources of information on COVID-19, (3) the reasons for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine, (4) the attitudes of family members toward the COVID-19 vaccine, (5) previous experience with other vaccines, (6) firm opposition to the vaccine (unvaccinated nurses), (7) reluctant acceptance (vaccinated nurses). It was shown that it is imperative for health authorities to adopt timely, documented, transparent, and consistent communication when carrying out public health campaigns, especially for vaccination.
在意大利,自2021年4月起,医护人员被要求接种新冠疫苗;若他们拒绝接种,则会被立即停职且无薪,直至接种疫苗。尽管有大量关于新冠疫情期间影响疫苗犹豫因素的定量研究,但关于疫苗拒绝原因的定性研究仍很缺乏。本研究旨在调查那些尽管被要求接种新冠疫苗却拒绝接种的护士现象及其拒绝原因。此外,还探讨了那些放弃这一立场的人的行为。这是一项采用扎根理论方法的定性研究。2022年5月至7月,通过Zoom对24名护士进行了虚拟访谈。从护士的经历中浮现出的反疫苗行为基于七个主题:(1)工作满意度,(2)新冠疫情的主要信息来源,(3)拒绝接种新冠疫苗的原因,(4)家庭成员对新冠疫苗的态度,(5)之前接种其他疫苗的经历,(6)坚决反对疫苗(未接种疫苗的护士),(7)勉强接受(已接种疫苗的护士)。结果表明,卫生当局在开展公共卫生运动,尤其是疫苗接种运动时,采取及时、有记录、透明且一致的沟通至关重要。