Department of Medicine, Division of Hematology/Oncology, University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center, University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Nature. 2023 Aug;620(7975):855-862. doi: 10.1038/s41586-023-06382-0. Epub 2023 Aug 2.
Patients from historically under-represented racial and ethnic groups are enrolled in cancer clinical trials at disproportionately low rates in the USA. As these patients often have limited English proficiency, we hypothesized that one barrier to their inclusion is the cost to investigators of translating consent documents. To test this hypothesis, we evaluated more than 12,000 consent events at a large cancer centre and assessed whether patients requiring translated consent documents would sign consent documents less frequently in studies lacking industry sponsorship (for which the principal investigator pays the translation costs) than for industry-sponsored studies (for which the translation costs are covered by the sponsor). Here we show that the proportion of consent events for patients with limited English proficiency in studies not sponsored by industry was approximately half of that seen in industry-sponsored studies. We also show that among those signing consent documents, the proportion of consent documents translated into the patient's primary language in studies without industry sponsorship was approximately half of that seen in industry-sponsored studies. The results suggest that the cost of consent document translation in trials not sponsored by industry could be a potentially modifiable barrier to the inclusion of patients with limited English proficiency.
在美国,来自代表性不足的种族和族裔群体的患者参与癌症临床试验的比例极低。由于这些患者的英语水平往往有限,我们假设他们参与的一个障碍是翻译知情同意书的费用。为了验证这一假设,我们在一家大型癌症中心评估了超过 12000 次知情同意事件,并评估了在缺乏行业赞助的研究中(主要研究者支付翻译费用),需要翻译知情同意书的患者签署知情同意书的频率是否低于行业赞助的研究(翻译费用由赞助商承担)。在这里,我们发现,在没有行业赞助的研究中,英语水平有限的患者的知情同意事件比例约为行业赞助研究的一半。我们还发现,在签署知情同意书的患者中,在没有行业赞助的研究中,将知情同意书翻译成患者主要语言的比例约为行业赞助研究的一半。研究结果表明,在没有行业赞助的试验中,知情同意书翻译的成本可能是限制英语水平有限的患者参与的一个潜在可改变的障碍。