Herbold Theresa, Engels Johannes M M
Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Hohenheim, 70599 Stuttgart, Germany.
Alliance of Bioversity International and CIAT, 00153 Rome, Italy.
Plants (Basel). 2023 Aug 4;12(15):2874. doi: 10.3390/plants12152874.
Genebanks are crucial for safeguarding global crop diversity but are themselves exposed to several risks. However, a scientific basis for identifying, assessing, and managing risks is still lacking. Addressing these research gaps, this study provides risk analysis for three key risk groups: natural hazards, political risks, and financial risks, carried out on a sample of 80 important national and international genebanks, comprising at least 4.78 million accessions or roughly 65% of the reported total of ex situ conserved accessions worldwide. The assessment tool of Munich Re "Natural Hazards Edition" allowed a location-specific comparison of the natural hazard exposure. Results showed that genebanks in the Asia-Pacific region are most exposed to natural hazards, while institutions in African and some Asian countries are rather vulnerable to political risks. Financing is a major problem for national genebanks in developing countries, whereas the Global Crop Diversity Trust achieved considerable financial security for international genebanks. Large differences in the risk exposure of genebanks exist, making a location- and institution-specific risk assessment indispensable. Moreover, there is significant room for improvement with respect to quality and risk management at genebanks. Transferring risks of genebanks to third parties is underdeveloped and should be used more widely.
基因库对于保护全球作物多样性至关重要,但自身也面临多种风险。然而,目前仍缺乏识别、评估和管理这些风险的科学依据。为填补这些研究空白,本研究对80个重要的国家和国际基因库样本进行了分析,涵盖至少478万个种质资源,约占全球异地保存种质资源报告总数的65%,针对自然灾害、政治风险和金融风险这三个关键风险类别开展了风险分析。慕尼黑再保险的“自然灾害版”评估工具实现了特定地点自然灾害暴露情况的比较。结果显示,亚太地区的基因库受自然灾害影响最大,而非洲和一些亚洲国家的机构则更容易受到政治风险的影响。融资是发展中国家国家基因库面临的一个主要问题,而全球作物多样性信托基金为国际基因库提供了可观的财务保障。基因库的风险暴露存在很大差异,因此进行特定地点和机构的风险评估必不可少。此外,基因库在质量和风险管理方面仍有很大的改进空间。将基因库的风险转移给第三方的做法尚不完善,应更广泛地加以应用。