Crabbe Deborah L, Richardson Briana T, Hausman Alice, Gardiner Heather
Temple Health Sciences Campus, Lewis Katz School of Medicine at Temple University, 3401 North Broad Street, Room 947 Parkinson Pavilion, Philadelphia, PA 19140, USA.
College of Public Health, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
J Natl Med Assoc. 2023 Oct;115(5):482-487. doi: 10.1016/j.jnma.2023.07.007. Epub 2023 Aug 19.
African Americans (AA) have been disproportionately affected with the COVID-19 disease experiencing 30%-60% of the deaths, while only making up 13% of the US population. Early data suggest that pregnant women and those with cardiovascular disease (CVD) may experience worse outcomes with severe coronavirus infection. There is an urgent need to incorporate AA and female perspectives into the design of research on the CVD complications related to COVID-19.
The goal of this project was to incorporate perspectives of AA and female patients in developing research priorities and AN agenda related to COVID-19. Objectives included: (a) develop a strong, research-ready partnership capable of executing PCOR, (b) creation of a research agenda and a set of priorities on racial/sex-specific CVD disparities in COVID-19 which reflects the perspectives of AA's and women; (c) long-term objective is creation of a set of research questions suitable for clinical research using the AHA Registry.
The project used principles of active and adult learning within the framework of capacity building to build a strong, patient-centered vision of research needs. Different methods of obtaining patient input were used to identify questions suitable for research using the America Heart Association COVID-19 CVD Quality Improvement Registry: focus groups and town halls to identify concerns and interests vis-à-vis CVD and COVID research; narrative medicine methods collected compelling real-life, COVID-19 health stories; a research advisory council reviewed and prioritized research questions.
Outcomes include a replicable method of obtaining patient-oriented input into the creation of a research agenda and a set of research priorities for COVID-19. Outputs include the establishment of a research advisory council and stakeholder training using the PCORI funded, PORTAL program resources; a catalogue of patient generated narratives on COVID-19 experiences in the voice of AAs and women, and a set of research questions suitable for research using the AHA Registry.
The project created a research ready stakeholder network, ready to develop a research agenda about COVID-19.
非裔美国人(AA)受新冠病毒病(COVID-19)的影响尤为严重,尽管仅占美国人口的13%,但却承受了30%-60%的死亡病例。早期数据表明,孕妇和心血管疾病(CVD)患者在感染严重冠状病毒时可能会有更糟糕的结局。迫切需要将非裔美国人和女性的观点纳入与COVID-19相关的心血管疾病并发症研究设计中。
本项目的目标是在制定与COVID-19相关的研究重点和议程时纳入非裔美国人和女性患者的观点。目标包括:(a)建立一个强大的、具备开展实用性临床研究能力的合作伙伴关系;(b)制定一项研究议程以及一系列关于COVID-19中种族/性别特定心血管疾病差异的优先事项,该议程要反映非裔美国人和女性的观点;(c)长期目标是利用美国心脏协会登记处创建一套适合临床研究的研究问题。
该项目在能力建设框架内运用主动学习和成人学习原则,以建立一个以患者为中心的强大研究需求愿景。采用不同方法获取患者意见,以确定适合使用美国心脏协会COVID-19心血管疾病质量改进登记处进行研究的问题:焦点小组和市政厅会议,以确定对心血管疾病和COVID研究的关注和兴趣;叙事医学方法收集引人关注的COVID-19真实健康故事;一个研究咨询委员会对研究问题进行审查并确定优先顺序。
成果包括一种可复制的方法,用于在制定研究议程和一套COVID-19研究优先事项时获取以患者为导向的意见。产出包括建立一个研究咨询委员会,并利用患者为中心的结果研究所(PCORI)资助的PORTAL项目资源对利益相关者进行培训;一份以非裔美国人和女性声音呈现的患者生成的COVID-19经历叙事目录,以及一套适合使用美国心脏协会登记处进行研究的研究问题。
该项目创建了一个随时准备开展研究的利益相关者网络,随时准备制定关于COVID-19的研究议程。