Department of Urology and Andrology, General Hospital Hall i.T., Hall in Tirol, Austria.
Training and Research in Urological Surgery and Technology (T.R.U.S.T.)-Group, Hall in Tirol, Austria.
World J Urol. 2023 Nov;41(11):3277-3285. doi: 10.1007/s00345-023-04565-y. Epub 2023 Aug 26.
To identify expert laser settings for BPH treatment and evaluate the application of preventive measures to reduce complications.
A survey was conducted after narrative literature research to identify relevant questions regarding laser use for BPH treatment (59 questions). Experts were asked for laser settings during specific clinical scenarios. Settings were compared for the reported laser types, and common settings and preventive measures were identified.
Twenty-two experts completed the survey with a mean filling time of 12.9 min. Ho:YAG, Thulium fiber laser (TFL), continuous wave (cw) Tm:YAG, pulsed Tm:YAG and Greenlight™ lasers are used by 73% (16/22), 50% (11/22), 23% (5/22), 13.6% (3/22) and 9.1% (2/22) of experts, respectively. All experts use anatomical enucleation of the prostate (EEP), preferentially in one- or two-lobe technique. Laser settings differ significantly between laser types, with median laser power for apical/main gland EEP of 75/94 W, 60/60 W, 100/100 W, 100/100 W, and 80/80 W for Ho:YAG, TFL, cwTm:YAG, pulsed Tm:YAG and Greenlight™ lasers, respectively (p = 0.02 and p = 0.005). However, power settings within the same laser source are similar. Pulse shapes for main gland EEP significantly differ between lasers with long and pulse shape modified (e.g., Moses, Virtual Basket) modes preferred for Ho:YAG and short pulse modes for TFL (p = 0.031).
Ho:YAG lasers no longer seem to be the mainstay of EEP. TFL lasers are generally used in pulsed mode though clinical applicability for quasi-continuous settings has recently been demonstrated. One and two-lobe techniques are beneficial regarding operative time and are used by most experts.
确定治疗 BPH 的专家级激光设置,并评估应用预防措施来减少并发症。
通过叙述性文献研究进行调查,以确定与 BPH 治疗激光使用相关的问题(59 个问题)。专家们被要求在特定的临床情况下提供激光设置。针对报告的激光类型比较了设置,并确定了常见的设置和预防措施。
22 名专家完成了调查,平均填写时间为 12.9 分钟。钬:YAG、铥光纤激光(TFL)、连续波(cw)铥:YAG、脉冲铥:YAG 和 Greenlight™激光分别被 73%(16/22)、50%(11/22)、23%(5/22)、13.6%(3/22)和 9.1%(2/22)的专家使用。所有专家都使用前列腺解剖切除术(EEP),优先使用单叶或双叶技术。激光设置在不同的激光类型之间存在显著差异,对于顶端/主要腺体 EEP 的中位激光功率分别为 75/94W、60/60W、100/100W、100/100W 和 80/80W,用于钬:YAG、TFL、cwTm:YAG、脉冲铥:YAG 和 Greenlight™激光(p=0.02 和 p=0.005)。然而,同一激光源内的功率设置相似。对于主要腺体 EEP,激光之间的脉冲形状显著不同,钬:YAG 更喜欢长脉冲形状和脉冲形状修改(如 Moses、Virtual Basket)模式,而 TFL 则更喜欢短脉冲模式(p=0.031)。
钬:YAG 激光似乎不再是 EEP 的主要手段。TFL 激光通常用于脉冲模式,尽管最近已经证明了准连续设置的临床适用性。单叶和双叶技术在手术时间方面具有优势,并且被大多数专家使用。