Sütcüoğlu Bengü Mutlu, Güler Melike
Lokman Hekim University, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Ankara, Turkey.
Lokman Hekim University, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Ankara, Turkey.
J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2024 Feb;37(1):39-44. doi: 10.1016/j.jpag.2023.08.004. Epub 2023 Aug 26.
There are many videos on contraception on YouTube and TikTok, and women around the world use video platforms extensively to seek health information from videos of uncertain reliability and quality. The main objective of this research was to evaluate the scientific reliability and quality of the most popular social media videos about contraceptive subdermal implants.
TikTok and YouTube videos were assessed separately by two gynecologists. The video quality was evaluated according to the DISCERN score, modified DISCERN score, and Global Quality Scale (GQS) score.
The study included the 100 most popular videos, 44 of which were uploaded by health care professionals. The median DISCERN score for videos shared by health care professionals was 50 (range 15-75), whereas it was 22 (range 15-56) for videos shared by independent users (P < .001). The median modified DISCERN score was 4 (min-max 0-5), and the median GQS score was 4 (min-max 1-5) for the videos uploaded by health care professionals. The modified DISCERN and GQS scores of TikTok videos were lower than those of YouTube videos (both P < .001).
Social media videos about contraceptive subdermal implants are popular and have been viewed tens of thousands of times, but the overall medical validity, which we evaluated according to the scoring systems, was poor. Despite the large number of videos, the content's quality and reliability are quite limited. There is a need to prioritize the education provided to patients by gynecologists, as well as to create high-quality content for YouTube and other similar platforms.
YouTube和TikTok上有许多关于避孕的视频,世界各地的女性广泛使用视频平台,从可靠性和质量不确定的视频中获取健康信息。本研究的主要目的是评估最受欢迎的关于皮下避孕植入物的社交媒体视频的科学可靠性和质量。
两位妇科医生分别对TikTok和YouTube视频进行评估。根据DISCERN评分、改良DISCERN评分和全球质量量表(GQS)评分对视频质量进行评估。
该研究纳入了100个最受欢迎的视频,其中44个由医疗保健专业人员上传。医疗保健专业人员分享的视频的DISCERN评分中位数为50(范围15 - 75),而独立用户分享的视频的DISCERN评分中位数为22(范围15 - 56)(P < .001)。医疗保健专业人员上传的视频的改良DISCERN评分中位数为4(最小值 - 最大值0 - 5),GQS评分中位数为4(最小值 - 最大值1 - 5)。TikTok视频的改良DISCERN评分和GQS评分低于YouTube视频(均P < .001)。
关于皮下避孕植入物的社交媒体视频很受欢迎,观看次数达数万次,但根据评分系统评估的整体医学有效性较差。尽管视频数量众多,但内容的质量和可靠性相当有限。需要优先考虑妇科医生为患者提供的教育,以及为YouTube和其他类似平台制作高质量的内容。