Barbhaiya Medha, Zuily Stephane, Naden Ray, Hendry Alison, Manneville Florian, Amigo Mary-Carmen, Amoura Zahir, Andrade Danieli, Andreoli Laura, Artim-Esen Bahar, Atsumi Tatsuya, Avcin Tadej, Belmont H Michael, Bertolaccini Maria Laura, Branch D Ware, Carvalheiras Graziela, Casini Alessandro, Cervera Ricard, Cohen Hannah, Costedoat-Chalumeau Nathalie, Crowther Mark, de Jesus Guilherme, Delluc Aurelien, Desai Sheetal, De Sancho Maria, Devreese Katrien M, Diz-Kucukkaya Reyhan, Duarte-Garcia Ali, Frances Camille, Garcia David, Gris Jean-Christophe, Jordan Natasha, Leaf Rebecca K, Kello Nina, Knight Jason S, Laskin Carl, Lee Alfred I, Legault Kimberly, Levine Steve R, Levy Roger A, Limper Maarten, Lockshin Michael D, Mayer-Pickel Karoline, Musial Jack, Meroni Pier Luigi, Orsolini Giovanni, Ortel Thomas L, Pengo Vittorio, Petri Michelle, Pons-Estel Guillermo, Gomez-Puerta Jose A, Raimboug Quentin, Roubey Robert, Sanna Giovanni, Seshan Surya V, Sciascia Savino, Tektonidou Maria G, Tincani Angela, Wahl Denis, Willis Rohan, Yelnik Cecile, Zuily Catherine, Guillemin Francis, Costenbader Karen, Erkan Doruk
Barbara Volcker Center for Women and Rheumatic Diseases, Hospital for Special Surgery, Weill Cornell Medicine, New York, New York.
Vascular Medicine Division, French National Referral Center for Systemic and Autoimmune Diseases, Université de Lorraine, Inserm, DCAC, and CHRU-Nancy, F-54000, Nancy, France.
Arthritis Rheumatol. 2023 Oct;75(10):1687-1702. doi: 10.1002/art.42624. Epub 2023 Aug 28.
To develop new antiphospholipid syndrome (APS) classification criteria with high specificity for use in observational studies and trials, jointly supported by the American College of Rheumatology (ACR) and EULAR.
This international multidisciplinary initiative included 4 phases: 1) Phase I, criteria generation by surveys and literature review; 2) Phase II, criteria reduction by modified Delphi and nominal group technique exercises; 3) Phase III, criteria definition, further reduction with the guidance of real-world patient scenarios, and weighting via consensus-based multicriteria decision analysis, and threshold identification; and 4) Phase IV, validation using independent adjudicators' consensus as the gold standard.
The 2023 ACR/EULAR APS classification criteria include an entry criterion of at least one positive antiphospholipid antibody (aPL) test within 3 years of identification of an aPL-associated clinical criterion, followed by additive weighted criteria (score range 1-7 points each) clustered into 6 clinical domains (macrovascular venous thromboembolism, macrovascular arterial thrombosis, microvascular, obstetric, cardiac valve, and hematologic) and 2 laboratory domains (lupus anticoagulant functional coagulation assays, and solid-phase enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays for IgG/IgM anticardiolipin and/or IgG/IgM anti-β -glycoprotein I antibodies). Patients accumulating at least 3 points each from the clinical and laboratory domains are classified as having APS. In the validation cohort, the new APS criteria versus the 2006 revised Sapporo classification criteria had a specificity of 99% versus 86%, and a sensitivity of 84% versus 99%.
These new ACR/EULAR APS classification criteria were developed using rigorous methodology with multidisciplinary international input. Hierarchically clustered, weighted, and risk-stratified criteria reflect the current thinking about APS, providing high specificity and a strong foundation for future APS research.
在美国风湿病学会(ACR)和欧洲抗风湿病联盟(EULAR)的共同支持下,制定具有高特异性的新抗磷脂综合征(APS)分类标准,用于观察性研究和试验。
这项国际多学科计划包括4个阶段:1)第一阶段,通过调查和文献综述生成标准;2)第二阶段,通过改良德尔菲法和名义群体技术练习减少标准;3)第三阶段,定义标准,在真实世界患者场景的指导下进一步减少标准,并通过基于共识的多标准决策分析进行加权,以及确定阈值;4)第四阶段,以独立评判者的共识作为金标准进行验证。
2023年ACR/EULAR APS分类标准包括一个入选标准,即在确定与抗磷脂抗体(aPL)相关的临床标准后3年内,至少有一次aPL检测呈阳性,随后是累加加权标准(每个标准得分范围为1 - 7分),分为6个临床领域(大血管静脉血栓栓塞、大血管动脉血栓形成、微血管、产科、心脏瓣膜和血液学)和2个实验室领域(狼疮抗凝物功能凝血试验,以及针对IgG/IgM抗心磷脂和/或IgG/IgM抗β2糖蛋白I抗体的固相酶联免疫吸附试验)。临床和实验室领域各累计至少3分的患者被分类为患有APS。在验证队列中,新的APS标准与2006年修订的札幌分类标准相比,特异性分别为99%和86%,敏感性分别为84%和99%。
这些新的ACR/EULAR APS分类标准是采用严格的方法制定的,有国际多学科的参与。分层聚类、加权和风险分层的标准反映了目前对APS的认识,具有高特异性,为未来APS研究提供了坚实基础。