Harris T, Brown G W, Bifulco A
Psychol Med. 1986 Aug;16(3):641-59. doi: 10.1017/s0033291700010394.
The inconclusiveness of the literature on the role of loss of parent in influencing psychiatric disorder in adulthood is well known. A number of reasons involving sampling, location and other methodological features, are given to account for these contradictory findings. A study specially designed to cope with these features is then described and basic results are reported. These indicate that, in a sample of women aged 18-65, loss of mother before the age of 17, either by death or by separation of one year or more, was associated with clinical depression in the year of interview. Loss of father by death was in no way associated with current depression, but separation from father showed a trend which, however, did not reach statistical significance. Control for other possible confounding factors did not change this patterning of results; these were further supported when psychiatric episodes earlier in adulthood were examined. Examination of the caregiving arrangements in childhood suggests that it is 'lack of care', defined in terms of neglect rather than simply hostile parental behaviour, which accounts for the raised rate of depression. Such 'lack of care' is more frequent after loss of mother than after loss of father.
关于早年丧亲对成年期精神障碍影响的文献尚无定论,这是众所周知的。人们给出了一些原因,包括抽样、地点和其他方法学特征,来解释这些相互矛盾的研究结果。随后描述了一项专门为应对这些特征而设计的研究,并报告了基本结果。这些结果表明,在18至65岁的女性样本中,17岁之前母亲因死亡或分居一年及以上而离世,与访谈当年的临床抑郁症有关。父亲因死亡而离世与当前抑郁症毫无关联,但与父亲分居则呈现出一种趋势,不过未达到统计学意义。对其他可能的混杂因素进行控制并没有改变这种结果模式;当对成年早期的精神疾病发作进行检查时,这些结果得到了进一步支持。对童年时期照料安排的研究表明,以忽视而非仅仅是父母的敌意行为来定义的“缺乏照料”,是导致抑郁症发病率上升的原因。这种“缺乏照料”在母亲离世后比在父亲离世后更为常见。