Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Computer Science, Faculty of Science, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
Int J Popul Data Sci. 2022 Oct 24;7(1):1756. doi: 10.23889/ijpds.v7i1.1756. eCollection 2022.
Developing decision support tools using data from a health care organization, to support care within that organization, is a promising paradigm to improve care delivery and population health. Descriptive epidemiology may be a valuable supplement to stakeholder input towards selection of potential initiatives and to inform methodological decisions throughout tool development. We additionally propose that to properly characterize complex populations in large-scale descriptive studies, both simple statistical and machine learning techniques can be useful.
To describe sociodemographic, clinical, and health care use characteristics of primary care clients served by the Alliance for Healthier Communities, which provides team-based primary health care through Community Health Centres (CHCs) across Ontario, Canada.
We used electronic health record data from adult ongoing primary care clients served by CHCs in 2009-2019. We performed traditional table-based summaries for each characteristic; and applied three unsupervised learning techniques to explore patterns of common condition co-occurrence, care provider teams, and care frequency.
There were 221,047 eligible clients. Sociodemographics: We described 13 characteristics, stratified by CHC type and client multimorbidity status. Clinical characteristics: Eleven-year prevalence of 24 investigated conditions ranged from 1% (Hepatitis C) to 63% (chronic musculoskeletal problem) with non-uniform risk across the care history; multimorbidity was common (81%) with variable co-occurrence patterns. Health care use characteristics: Most care was provided by physician and nursing providers, with heterogeneous combinations of other provider types. A subset of clients had many issues addressed within single-visits and there was within- and between-client variability in care frequency. In addition to substantive findings, we discuss methodological considerations for future decision support initiatives.
We demonstrated the use of methods from statistics and machine learning, applied with an epidemiological lens, to provide an overview of a complex primary care population and lay a foundation for stakeholder engagement and decision support tool development.
利用医疗保健组织的数据开发决策支持工具,以支持该组织内的护理,是改善护理提供和人口健康的一种有前途的范例。描述性流行病学可能是对利益相关者输入的有价值的补充,有助于选择潜在的举措,并在整个工具开发过程中为方法学决策提供信息。我们还提出,为了在大规模描述性研究中正确描述复杂人群,简单的统计和机器学习技术都可以是有用的。
描述安大略省通过社区卫生中心(CHC)提供基于团队的初级保健的联盟为初级保健客户提供的服务的社会人口统计学、临床和医疗保健使用特征,该联盟为初级保健客户提供服务。
我们使用了 2009 年至 2019 年期间在 CHC 接受服务的成年持续初级保健客户的电子健康记录数据。我们对每个特征进行了传统的基于表格的摘要;并应用了三种无监督学习技术来探索常见疾病共病、护理提供者团队和护理频率的模式。
有 221,047 名符合条件的客户。社会人口统计学特征:我们描述了 13 个特征,按 CHC 类型和客户多重疾病状况进行分层。临床特征:24 种调查疾病的 11 年患病率从 1%(丙型肝炎)到 63%(慢性肌肉骨骼问题)不等,在整个护理历史中风险分布不均;多重疾病很常见(81%),且共病模式不同。医疗保健使用特征:大多数护理由医生和护理提供者提供,其他提供者类型的组合也各不相同。一部分客户在单次就诊中解决了许多问题,并且在护理频率方面存在个体内和个体间的差异。除了实质性的发现,我们还讨论了未来决策支持计划的方法学考虑因素。
我们展示了统计和机器学习方法的应用,从流行病学的角度来看,为复杂的初级保健人群提供了概述,并为利益相关者参与和决策支持工具的开发奠定了基础。