Penn State Berks, Reading, PA, USA.
Oregon State University, OR, USA.
J Biomech. 2023 Oct;159:111776. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2023.111776. Epub 2023 Aug 23.
Undergraduate research is commonly performed in many STEM disciplines and has a wide array of benefits for students, laboratories, principal investigators, and institutions. While many fields have assessed best practices and the cost-benefit analysis of incorporating undergraduates in research, this has not yet been addressed in biomechanics. This paper represents the perspectives of seven members of the American Society of Biomechanics (ASB) Teaching Biomechanics Interest Group (TBIG). These TBIG members discussed their own experience regarding the opportunities, challenges, and benefits of undergraduate research and this perspective paper presents the commonalities found during these interactions. The TBIG members reported that undergraduate research was assessed similarly to graduate student research, which often led to an underestimation of productivity for both the student and overall lab output. While undergraduate researchers are not often responsible for publications and grant funding, they are instrumental in lab productivity in other ways, such as through human subject approvals, conference abstract presentations, student thesis projects, and more. Students benefit from these experiences, not necessarily by continuing in research, but by learning skills and making connections which further them in any career. While this perspective presents the experience of seven professors in the United States, future studies should further assess the cost-benefit relationship of working with undergraduates in biomechanics research on a global scale. A clearer picture of this analysis could benefit students, faculty, and administrators in making difficult decisions about lab productivity and assessment.
本科生研究在许多 STEM 学科中很常见,对学生、实验室、首席研究员和机构都有很多好处。虽然许多领域已经评估了最佳实践和将本科生纳入研究的成本效益分析,但这在生物力学领域尚未得到解决。本文代表了美国生物力学学会(ASB)教学生物力学兴趣小组(TBIG)的七位成员的观点。这些 TBIG 成员讨论了他们自己在本科生研究方面的机会、挑战和收益的经验,而这篇观点文章则介绍了在这些互动中发现的共同点。TBIG 成员报告说,本科生研究的评估与研究生研究相似,这往往导致学生和整个实验室的生产力被低估。虽然本科生研究人员通常不负责出版物和资助申请,但他们在其他方面对实验室的生产力也很有帮助,例如通过人体研究批准、会议摘要演示、学生论文项目等。学生从这些经验中受益,不一定是通过继续研究,而是通过学习技能和建立联系,从而在任何职业中取得进步。虽然本观点介绍了美国七位教授的经验,但未来的研究应该进一步评估在全球范围内从事生物力学本科生研究的成本效益关系。这种分析的更清晰的图景可以使学生、教师和管理人员在关于实验室生产力和评估的困难决策中受益。