Rockville, MD, USA
Behav Brain Sci. 2023 Sep 11;46:e226. doi: 10.1017/S0140525X22002400.
Burt formulates her critique at a general level of abstraction that highlights the methodological deficiencies of sociogenomics without also calling attention to precisely the same deficiencies in the social science model she seeks to defend against its encroachments. What might have been a methodological bulwark against the excesses of sociogenomics is instead a one-sided critique that merely renews its charter.
Burt 在一个高度抽象的层面上提出了她的批评,强调了社会基因组学的方法论缺陷,而没有同时引起人们对她试图捍卫的社会科学模型的同样缺陷的关注。本来可以成为反对社会基因组学过度行为的方法论堡垒的东西,现在却成了一种片面的批评,只是在重申它的章程。