Mohsen Mohammed Al-Qarni Somayah, Mohamed Mohamed Bayoumy Hala, Alosaimi Dalyal
Intensive Care Unit, Prince Mishary Bin Saud Hospital, Al Baha, SAU.
College of Nursing, Cairo University, Cairo, EGY.
Cureus. 2023 Aug 21;15(8):e43845. doi: 10.7759/cureus.43845. eCollection 2023 Aug.
Handover is considered a basic nursing practice in which a patient's care information is moved to another nurse. Handover of patients after surgery is critical due to a number of care transitions, the presence of a surgical procedure, and the influence of anesthesia. High-quality postoperative handover is essential to safe patient care. Few studies have been conducted to evaluate the quality of current postoperative handover practices and the factors contributing to the quality of such processes, especially in Saudi Arabia.
The present research aimed at evaluating nurses' perceptions of postoperative handover quality and assessing factors impacting this process. This cross-sectional study targeted registered nurses with at least one year of professional experience who were actively involved in the conduction of postoperative handovers across various surgical departments. A total sample of 143 nurses was selected via a convenient sampling technique. Study instruments included Handover Quality Rating Form, patient status, and nurses' background characteristics.
Overall, postoperative handover quality was perceived as high by handing over and receiving nurses. Generally, 55.2% of nurses agreed on the different items supporting the positive circumstance for handover, and 92.3% agreed on the good conduct of handover compared to only 7.69% disagreement (p˂0.001). Significant agreements were observed for teamworking (p˂0.001), as well as four indicators (out of five) measuring the overall handover quality (p<0.001). The type of involved departments impacted significantly the handover quality perception (p=0.004). The respondents' age had a significant effect on quality (p=0.036), as well as circumstances of postoperative handover (p=0.046). Moreover, significant statistical differences were found for the circumstance of handover (p=0.031), as well as teamwork (p=0.019) according to the nurses' roles. Finally, the patient's blood circulation and respiration had a significant effect (p=0.023, p=0.033, respectively), as did the patient's level of consciousness (p=0.006) in the nurses' perception of the overall postoperative handover quality.
Postoperative handover quality was highly perceived by nurses. This research explored a multitude of factors such as patient health status and nurses' socio-demographic variables and their impact on nurses' perception of handover quality. Several nurse and patient-related factors were found to impact the handover process. This current research provided findings that could direct future improvements in nursing handover practice to ensure high-quality patient care.
交接班被视为一项基本的护理操作,即把患者的护理信息传递给另一名护士。由于存在多次护理交接、手术操作以及麻醉的影响,术后患者的交接班至关重要。高质量的术后交接班对于患者的安全护理至关重要。很少有研究对当前术后交接班实践的质量以及影响此类过程质量的因素进行评估,尤其是在沙特阿拉伯。
本研究旨在评估护士对术后交接班质量的看法,并评估影响这一过程的因素。这项横断面研究的对象是具有至少一年专业经验且积极参与各外科术后交接班工作的注册护士。通过便利抽样技术共选取了143名护士作为样本。研究工具包括交接班质量评定表、患者状况以及护士的背景特征。
总体而言,交班护士和接班护士都认为术后交接班质量较高。一般来说,55.2%的护士认同支持良好交接班情况的不同项目,92.3%的护士认同交接班工作开展良好,而只有7.69%的护士持不同意见(p<0.001)。在团队协作方面(p<0.001)以及衡量总体交接班质量的五个指标中的四个指标方面(p<0.001)观察到显著的一致性。涉及的科室类型对交接班质量认知有显著影响(p=0.004)。受访者的年龄对质量(p=0.036)以及术后交接班情况(p=0.046)有显著影响。此外,根据护士的角色,在交接班情况(p=0.031)以及团队协作(p=0.019)方面发现了显著的统计学差异。最后,患者的血液循环和呼吸(分别为p=0.023、p=0.033)以及患者的意识水平(p=0.006)在护士对总体术后交接班质量的认知中具有显著影响。
护士对术后交接班质量评价较高。本研究探讨了众多因素,如患者健康状况和护士的社会人口统计学变量及其对护士交接班质量认知的影响。发现了一些与护士和患者相关的因素会影响交接班过程。当前的这项研究提供了一些结果,可指导未来护理交接班实践的改进,以确保高质量的患者护理。