Walters Suzan M, Kerr Jelani, Cano Manuel, Earnshaw Valerie, Link Bruce
School of Global Public Health, New York University, New York, NY.
Center for Drug Use and HIV/HCV Research, New York, NY.
Stigma Health. 2023 Aug;8(3):325-343. doi: 10.1037/sah0000426. Epub 2023 Mar 2.
Recent evidence points to racial and ethnic disparities in drug-related deaths and health conditions. Informed by stigma, intersectionality, intersectional stigma, and fundamental cause theories, we aimed to explore whether intersectional stigma was a fundamental cause of health. We document key events and policies over time and find that when progress is made new mechanisms emerge that negatively affect health outcomes for Black and Hispanic persons. We then focus on intersectional stigma targeting Black and Hispanic persons who use drugs. We document that when a person, or group of people, occupy multiple stigmatized identities the processes of stigmatization and scapegoating are particularly persistent and pernicious since people and groups can be stigmatized and scapegoated on varying intersections. We propose that an intersectional stigma framework allows for a better understanding of observed patterns over time, thereby providing a better guide for policies and interventions designed to reduce disparities. As a framework, intersectional stigma aims to recognize that when different sources of stigma collide, a new set of circumstances is created for those who reside in the intersection. We conclude that intersectional stigma is a fundamental cause of health inequities and provide policy recommendations aimed at dismantling intersectional stigma processes and mitigating the effects of intersectional stigmas to ultimately promote better health outcomes for Black and Hispanic persons who use drugs.
近期证据表明,在与毒品相关的死亡和健康状况方面存在种族和族裔差异。基于污名、交叉性、交叉污名和根本原因理论,我们旨在探讨交叉污名是否是健康的根本原因。我们记录了不同时期的关键事件和政策,发现每当取得进展时,就会出现新的机制,对黑人和西班牙裔人群的健康结果产生负面影响。然后,我们将重点放在针对吸毒的黑人和西班牙裔人群的交叉污名上。我们记录到,当一个人或一群人具有多种被污名化的身份时,污名化和替罪羊现象的过程就会特别持久且有害,因为人们和群体可能会在不同的交叉点上被污名化和成为替罪羊。我们提出,交叉污名框架有助于更好地理解长期以来观察到的模式,从而为旨在减少差异的政策和干预措施提供更好的指导。作为一个框架,交叉污名旨在认识到,当不同的污名来源相互碰撞时,会为处于交叉点的人创造一系列新的情况。我们得出结论,交叉污名是健康不平等的根本原因,并提供政策建议,旨在消除交叉污名过程,减轻交叉污名的影响,最终为吸毒的黑人和西班牙裔人群促进更好的健康结果。