Muskett A D, McGreevy J M
Postgrad Med J. 1986 Oct;62(732):925-8. doi: 10.1136/pgmj.62.732.925.
Clinical data from two hundred consecutive patients undergoing surgical procedures at the Salt Lake City VA Hospital form the basis of this study. Results of nine commonly ordered preoperative tests (blood count, differential, electrolytes, chemistry panel, urinalysis, prothrombin time, partial thromboplastin time, electrocardiogram, and chest X-ray) were matched with the preoperative history and physical examination and the outcome of surgery in each patient. Each test was examined by the frequency with which it was ordered, the frequency with which it was abnormal, and the frequency with which the abnormal result affected preoperative care. A prevalence of medical illness was found in this population, with 47.5% having a major cardiovascular diagnosis, 35.5% a metabolic or endocrine disease, and 28% a major pulmonary diagnosis. A total of 1271 tests were performed, with 477 (35.5%) showing some abnormality. However, only 76 (5.9%) changed the patient's management before surgery. All but five of these abnormalities were predictable from the clinical evaluation and these five were minor. The overall postoperative complication rate was 9%. No complication was attributed to the omission of a preoperative test. No surgical cases were cancelled during the study period based solely on a preoperative test. We conclude that many preoperative tests can be safely eliminated by ordering only those based on a specific abnormality in the history or physical examination, resulting in more cost-effective surgical care.
本研究基于盐湖城退伍军人事务医院连续200例接受外科手术患者的临床数据。将九项常用术前检查(血细胞计数、分类计数、电解质、生化指标、尿液分析、凝血酶原时间、部分凝血活酶时间、心电图和胸部X线)的结果与每位患者的术前病史、体格检查及手术结果进行匹配。对每项检查,均按照其开具的频率、结果异常的频率以及异常结果影响术前护理的频率进行分析。研究发现该人群中存在多种疾病,47.5%患有重大心血管疾病,35.5%患有代谢或内分泌疾病,28%患有重大肺部疾病。总共进行了1271项检查,其中477项(35.5%)显示存在某种异常。然而,只有76项(5.9%)在手术前改变了患者的治疗方案。除了其中五项异常外,其余所有异常均可通过临床评估预测,而这五项异常并不严重。总体术后并发症发生率为9%。没有并发症归因于术前检查的遗漏。在研究期间,没有任何手术病例仅因术前检查而取消。我们得出结论,仅根据病史或体格检查中的特定异常情况开具术前检查,许多术前检查可以安全地省去,从而实现更具成本效益的外科护理。