Zanasi Francesca, Arpino Bruno, Bordone Valeria, Hank Karsten
University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
University of Padua, Padua, Italy.
Eur J Ageing. 2023 Sep 25;20(1):37. doi: 10.1007/s10433-023-00785-8.
We investigate (a) how the proportion of European grandparents providing childcare changed over a period of 15 years, (b) how these proportions differ by gender and education, and (c) how countries not covered in earlier analyses fit into previously identified regional patterns of grandparental childcare in Europe. Using data from Waves 1, 2, and 8 of the Survey of Health, Ageing and Retirement in Europe (SHARE), our descriptive analysis provides estimates of the prevalence and intensity of grandparental childcare in 26 European countries as well as of the changes therein over time and across socio-demographically defined groups. Overall, the prevalence and intensity of grandparental childcare in Europe has remained fairly stable over time, with minor increases. Proportions of grandparents providing any childcare strongly vary, however, across countries (from 24 to 60%). Grandmothers are generally more likely to provide childcare than grandfathers, while differences based on educational levels are less clear-cut. Central and southeastern Europe, representing the bulk of the 'new' countries in the analysis, exhibit patterns of grandparental childcare closely resembling those observed in Mediterranean countries. Our analysis revealed an overall stability over time rather than change in grandparents' provision of childcare in Europe, with substantial variations across welfare state regimes and within countries when accounting for grandparents' gender and educational levels. Including countries that had previously been excluded from other studies challenges the 'narrative' that has emerged around a negative macrolevel association between the provision of extensive and intensive grandparental childcare.
(a)在15年的时间里,提供儿童照料的欧洲祖父母比例是如何变化的;(b)这些比例在性别和教育程度上有何差异;(c)早期分析未涵盖的国家如何融入欧洲先前确定的祖父母照料区域模式。利用欧洲健康、老龄化和退休调查(SHARE)第1波、第2波和第8波的数据,我们的描述性分析提供了26个欧洲国家祖父母照料的患病率和强度估计,以及随着时间推移和社会人口统计学定义群体的变化情况。总体而言,欧洲祖父母照料的患病率和强度随时间保持相对稳定,略有上升。然而,提供任何儿童照料的祖父母比例在各国之间差异很大(从24%到60%)。祖母通常比祖父更有可能提供儿童照料,而基于教育水平的差异则不太明显。中欧和东南欧,在分析中代表了大部分“新”国家,其祖父母照料模式与在地中海国家观察到的模式非常相似。我们的分析揭示了随着时间推移,欧洲祖父母提供儿童照料的总体稳定性而非变化,在考虑祖父母的性别和教育水平时,福利国家制度之间以及国家内部存在很大差异。纳入先前被其他研究排除的国家,挑战了围绕广泛和密集的祖父母照料提供之间的负面宏观层面关联所形成的“说法”。