Department of Social Work, Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, Monash University, Melbourne, VIC 3145, Australia.
Mental Health and Wellbeing Program, Eastern Health, Centre for Education and Research, Melbourne, VIC 3128, Australia.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023 Sep 20;20(18):6787. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20186787.
Recovery-oriented practice (ROP) is a framework focusing on recovery through hope, choice, and meaning, to live with or without enduring symptoms and challenges.
To examine clinicians' attitudes about the involvement of service users and family or supporters in ROP.
A bespoke Qualtrics survey obtained views of mental health clinicians working in an Australian public mental health service about service user and family involvement in ROP, using a five-point Likert scale of agreement and free-text responses. Data were analysed with descriptive statistics and content analysis methods.
Two hundred and three clinicians completed the survey. Most (79%) clinicians agreed with the statement that service users want clinicians to use ROP principles, and the majority (63%) also 'strongly believed' that ROP made a difference to service users' mental health outcomes. Only 15% 'strongly agreed' and 57% somewhat agreed with the statement that service users know what treatment is best for them, and only 20% of clinicians 'strongly agreed' that supporters of service users believed in and wanted ROP for their family member or friend.
This study adds to the literature on clinicians' views about ROP and shows that although clinicians are supportive of ROP, they also express substantial ambivalence about whether service users and families know what treatment is best. For ROP implementation to be successful, workforce training needs to support clinicians to reflect on these views with service users and families, and to encourage supported decision making. Future studies should focus on changes in clinicians' views and practice post ROP training.
以康复为导向的实践(ROP)是一种关注通过希望、选择和意义实现康复的框架,以应对或不应对持久症状和挑战。
探讨临床医生对服务使用者和家庭或支持者参与 ROP 的态度。
使用澳大利亚公共心理健康服务机构的心理健康临床医生专用的 Qualtrics 调查,采用 5 点李克特量表对服务使用者和家庭参与 ROP 的态度进行了评估,并对自由文本回复进行了分析。采用描述性统计和内容分析方法对数据进行了分析。
共有 203 名临床医生完成了调查。大多数(79%)临床医生同意服务使用者希望临床医生使用 ROP 原则的说法,大多数(63%)也“强烈相信”ROP 对服务使用者的心理健康结果有影响。只有 15%“强烈同意”,57%“有些同意”服务使用者知道哪种治疗最适合他们的说法,只有 20%的临床医生“强烈同意”服务使用者的支持者相信并希望他们的家人或朋友接受 ROP。
本研究增加了关于临床医生对 ROP 看法的文献,并表明,尽管临床医生支持 ROP,但他们也对服务使用者和家庭是否知道哪种治疗最适合存在很大的矛盾心理。为了 ROP 的成功实施,需要对劳动力进行培训,以支持临床医生与服务使用者和家庭一起反思这些观点,并鼓励支持性决策。未来的研究应侧重于 ROP 培训后临床医生观点和实践的变化。