Noteboom Lisa, Nijs Anouk, Beek Peter J, van der Helm Frans C T, Hoozemans Marco J M
Department of Human Movement Sciences, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam Movement Sciences, 1081 BT Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Department of Biomechanical Engineering, Delft University of Technology, 2628 CD Delft, The Netherlands.
Sports (Basel). 2023 Sep 5;11(9):170. doi: 10.3390/sports11090170.
Muscle overload injuries in strength training might be prevented by providing personalized feedback about muscle load during a workout. In the present study, a new muscle load feedback application, which monitors and visualizes the loading of specific muscle groups, was developed in collaboration with the fitness company Gymstory. The aim of the present study was to examine the effectiveness of this feedback application in managing muscle load balance, muscle load level, and muscle soreness, and to evaluate how its actual use was experienced. Thirty participants were randomly distributed into 'control', 'partial feedback', and 'complete feedback' groups and monitored for eight workouts using the automatic exercise tracking system of Gymstory. The control group received no feedback, while the partial feedback group received a visualization of their estimated cumulative muscle load after each exercise, and the participants in the complete feedback group received this visualization together with suggestions for the next exercise to target muscle groups that had not been loaded yet. Generalized estimation equations (GEEs) were used to compare muscle load balance and soreness, and a one-way ANOVA was used to compare user experience scores between groups. The complete feedback group showed a significantly better muscle load balance (β = -18.9; 95% CI [-29.3, -8.6]), adhered better to the load suggestion provided by the application (significant interactions), and had higher user experience scores for Attractiveness ( = 0.036), Stimulation ( = 0.031), and Novelty ( = 0.019) than the control group. No significant group differences were found for muscle soreness. Based on these results, it was concluded that personal feedback about muscle load in the form of a muscle body map in combination with exercise suggestions can effectively guide strength training practitioners towards certain load levels and more balanced cumulative muscle loads. This application has potential to be applied in strength training practice as a training tool and may help in preventing muscle overload.
在力量训练中,通过在锻炼期间提供有关肌肉负荷的个性化反馈,可能预防肌肉过载损伤。在本研究中,与健身公司Gymstory合作开发了一种新的肌肉负荷反馈应用程序,该程序可监测并可视化特定肌肉群的负荷情况。本研究的目的是检验这种反馈应用程序在管理肌肉负荷平衡、肌肉负荷水平和肌肉酸痛方面的有效性,并评估其实际使用体验。30名参与者被随机分为“对照组”、“部分反馈组”和“完整反馈组”,并使用Gymstory的自动运动跟踪系统进行了8次锻炼监测。对照组未收到反馈,部分反馈组在每次锻炼后收到其估计累积肌肉负荷的可视化信息,而完整反馈组的参与者除了收到此可视化信息外,还收到针对尚未加载的目标肌肉群的下一次锻炼建议。使用广义估计方程(GEEs)比较肌肉负荷平衡和酸痛情况,并使用单因素方差分析比较组间用户体验得分。完整反馈组的肌肉负荷平衡明显更好(β = -18.9;95%置信区间[-29.3, -8.6]),对应用程序提供的负荷建议的依从性更好(显著交互作用),并且在吸引力( = 0.036)、刺激性( = 0.031)和新颖性( = 0.019)方面的用户体验得分高于对照组。在肌肉酸痛方面未发现显著的组间差异。基于这些结果,得出的结论是,以肌肉身体图形式结合锻炼建议的肌肉负荷个人反馈可以有效地指导力量训练从业者达到特定的负荷水平,并实现更平衡的累积肌肉负荷。该应用程序有潜力作为一种训练工具应用于力量训练实践中,并可能有助于预防肌肉过载。