Animal Breeding and Genomics, Wageningen University and Research, P.O. Box 338, 6700 AH, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Genet Sel Evol. 2023 Sep 28;55(1):67. doi: 10.1186/s12711-023-00840-z.
Harmful social behaviours, such as injurious feather pecking in poultry and tail biting in swine, reduce animal welfare and production efficiency. While these behaviours are heritable, selective breeding is still limited due to a lack of individual phenotyping methods for large groups and proper genetic models. In the near future, large-scale longitudinal data on social behaviours will become available, e.g. through computer vision techniques, and appropriate genetic models will be needed to analyse such data. In this paper, we investigated prospects for genetic improvement of social traits recorded in large groups by (1) developing models to simulate and analyse large-scale longitudinal data on social behaviours, and (2) investigating required sample sizes to obtain reasonable accuracies of estimated genetic parameters and breeding values (EBV).
Latent traits were defined as representing tendencies of individuals to be engaged in social interactions by distinguishing between performer and recipient effects. Animal movement was assumed random and without genetic variation, and performer and recipient interaction effects were assumed constant over time. Based on the literature, observed-scale heritabilities ([Formula: see text]) of performer and recipient effects were both set to 0.05, 0.1, or 0.2, and the genetic correlation ([Formula: see text]) between those effects was set to - 0.5, 0, or 0.5. Using agent-based modelling, we simulated ~ 200,000 interactions for 2000 animals (~ 1000 interactions per animal) with a half-sib family structure. Variance components and breeding values were estimated with a general linear mixed model. The estimated genetic parameters did not differ significantly from the true values. When all individuals and interactions were included in the analysis, the accuracy of EBV was 0.61, 0.70, and 0.76 for [Formula: see text] = 0.05, 0.1, and 0.2, respectively (for [Formula: see text]= 0). Including 2000 individuals each with only ~ 100 interactions, already yielded promising accuracies of 0.47, 0.60, and 0.71 for [Formula: see text] = 0.05, 0.1, and 0.2, respectively (with [Formula: see text] = 0). Similar results were found with [Formula: see text] of - 0.5 or 0.5.
We developed models to simulate and genetically analyse social behaviours for animals that are kept in large groups, anticipating the availability of large-scale longitudinal data in the near future. We obtained promising accuracies of EBV with ~ 100 interactions per individual, which would correspond to a few weeks of recording. Therefore, we conclude that animal breeding can be a promising strategy to improve social behaviours in livestock.
有害的社会行为,如禽类的啄羽和猪的咬尾,会降低动物福利和生产效率。虽然这些行为是可遗传的,但由于缺乏针对大群体的个体表型方法和适当的遗传模型,选择性育种仍然受到限制。在不久的将来,通过计算机视觉技术等手段,将获得大量关于社会行为的纵向数据,因此需要适当的遗传模型来分析这些数据。本文通过(1)开发模拟和分析大型群体中社会行为的大规模纵向数据的模型,(2)研究获得合理估计遗传参数和育种值(EBV)的准确性所需的样本量,探讨了通过遗传改良记录在大群体中的社会特征的前景。
隐性特征被定义为通过区分执行者和接受者的效应来代表个体参与社会互动的倾向。假设动物的运动是随机的,没有遗传变异,执行者和接受者的相互作用效应随时间保持不变。基于文献,我们将执行者和接受者效应的观察尺度遗传力([Formula: see text])分别设定为 0.05、0.1 或 0.2,并将这些效应之间的遗传相关性([Formula: see text])设定为-0.5、0 或 0.5。使用基于主体的建模,我们模拟了 2000 只动物(1000 个相互作用)的200,000 个相互作用(每个动物约 1000 个相互作用),具有半同胞家族结构。使用一般线性混合模型估计方差分量和育种值。估计的遗传参数与真实值没有显著差异。当所有个体和相互作用都包含在分析中时,[Formula: see text] = 0.05、0.1 和 0.2 时 EBV 的准确性分别为 0.61、0.70 和 0.76(对于[Formula: see text]= 0)。包含 2000 个个体,每个个体仅具有~100 个相互作用,对于[Formula: see text] = 0.05、0.1 和 0.2,仍然分别产生了 0.47、0.60 和 0.71 的有希望的准确性(对于[Formula: see text] = 0)。当[Formula: see text]为-0.5 或 0.5 时,也得到了类似的结果。
我们开发了用于模拟和遗传分析大型群体中动物社会行为的模型,预计在不久的将来将获得大量的大规模纵向数据。我们通过每个个体大约 100 次交互作用获得了有希望的 EBV 准确性,这相当于数周的记录。因此,我们得出结论,动物育种可能是改善家畜社会行为的一种很有前途的策略。