University of Eastern Finland, Kuopio, Finland.
Tampere University Hospital, Tampere, Finland.
Stud Health Technol Inform. 2023 Oct 20;309:233-237. doi: 10.3233/SHTI230785.
A 'Do Not Attempt Resuscitation' (DNAR) order is one of the most important yet difficult medical decisions. Despite the recent European guidelines, health care professionals (HCPs) in general perceive challenges in making a DNAR order. We aimed to evaluate the types of problems related to DNAR order making. A link to a web-based multiple-choice questionnaire including open-ended questions was sent by e-mail to all physicians and nurses working in the Tampere University Hospital special responsibility area covering a catchment area of 900,000 Finns. The questionnaire covered issues on DNAR order making, its meaning and documentation. Here we report the analysis of the open-ended questions, examined based on the Ottawa Decision Support Framework with expanded individual decisional needs categories. Qualitative data describing respondents' opinions (N=648) regarding problems related to DNAR order decision making were analysed using Atlas.ti 23.12 software. In total, 599 statements (phrases) dealing with inadequate advice, information, emotional support, and instrumental help were identified. Our results show that HCPs experience lack of support in DNAR decision making on multiple levels. Digital decision-making support integrated into electronic patient records (EPR) to assure timely and clearly visible DNAR orders could be beneficial.
“不复苏”(Do Not Attempt Resuscitation,DNAR)医嘱是最重要但也是最困难的医疗决策之一。尽管有最近的欧洲指南,但医疗保健专业人员(HCP)在做出 DNAR 医嘱方面普遍存在挑战。我们旨在评估与制定 DNAR 医嘱相关的问题类型。通过电子邮件向坦佩雷大学医院特殊责任区的所有医生和护士发送了一个链接到基于网络的多项选择问卷,该区域涵盖了 90 万芬兰人的集水区。问卷涵盖了关于 DNAR 医嘱制定、其含义和记录的问题。在这里,我们报告了根据渥太华决策支持框架(Ottawa Decision Support Framework)对开放式问题进行的分析,该框架扩展了个人决策需求类别。使用 Atlas.ti 23.12 软件分析了描述与 DNAR 医嘱决策相关的问题的受访者意见(N=648)的定性数据。总共确定了 599 条(短语)与建议不足、信息不足、情感支持不足和工具性帮助不足有关的语句。我们的结果表明,HCP 在多个层面上都缺乏制定 DNAR 决策的支持。将数字决策支持集成到电子病历(EPR)中,以确保及时且清晰可见的 DNAR 医嘱可能会有所帮助。