Kholief Amr, Ali Ahmed, Elwany Samy, Ahmed Shahzada, Youssef Ahmed, Zahran Mohamed
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Alexandria University Hospital, Alexandria, Egypt.
Ear, Nose, and Throat Department, University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
Int Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2023 Sep 14;27(4):e620-e624. doi: 10.1055/s-0042-1759604. eCollection 2023 Oct.
The three-dimensional (3D) endoscope is considered a new surgical tool used in different approaches in intranasal and anterior skull base surgical procedures. There are many advantages of 3D over two-dimensional (2D) endoscopy that have been demonstrated in clinical applications, surgical training, and different experimental studies. To show the difference between using the 3D and 2D endoscopes during endonasal and anterior skull base surgery and its importance. Our study is divided into two phases (clinical and cadaveric phases). In the clinical study we, have performed 52 endonasal and anterior skull base surgical procedures (26 study cases and 26 control cases). We recorded accuracy, duration, and intraoperative complication for each case. The cadaveric study was performed on three cadavers. Differences in accuracy and dissection time were recorded using 3D and 2D endoscopy for each side chosen by randomization. In the clinical study, the cases done by 3D endoscope were significantly faster and more accurate with less intraoperative complications compared with cases done using 2D endoscope. In cadaveric dissection, while using 3D endoscope, there was better depth of perception regarding the anatomical landmarks compared with 2D endoscope. Three-dimensional endoscopy is an advanced instrument that allows better training for the coming generation of ear, nose, and throat surgeons. Both clinical and cadaveric studies offer a promising outcome in both endonasal and anterior skull base surgery.
三维(3D)内窥镜被认为是一种新型手术工具,用于鼻内和前颅底手术的不同术式。在临床应用、手术培训及不同的实验研究中,3D内窥镜相较于二维(2D)内窥镜具有诸多优势。
为了展示在鼻内和前颅底手术中使用3D和2D内窥镜的差异及其重要性。
我们的研究分为两个阶段(临床阶段和尸体研究阶段)。在临床研究中,我们进行了52例鼻内和前颅底手术(26例研究病例和26例对照病例)。我们记录了每个病例的准确性、手术时长及术中并发症。尸体研究在三具尸体上进行。通过随机选择每侧,使用3D和2D内窥镜记录准确性和解剖时间的差异。
在临床研究中,与使用2D内窥镜的病例相比,使用3D内窥镜的病例手术速度明显更快、更准确,术中并发症更少。在尸体解剖中,使用3D内窥镜时,与2D内窥镜相比,对解剖标志的深度感知更好。
三维内窥镜是一种先进的器械,可为下一代耳鼻喉科医生提供更好的培训。临床研究和尸体研究在鼻内和前颅底手术中均取得了有前景的结果。