Health Services Management Research Center, Institute for Futures Studies in Health, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran.
Department of Health Management Policy and Economics, Faculty of Management and Medical Information Sciences, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023 Oct 27;23(1):1169. doi: 10.1186/s12913-023-10113-6.
Hemovigilance is a set of monitoring methods that covers the blood transfusion chain, from collecting blood and blood products to monitoring the blood recipients. To this end, any error in this process can have serious and irreparable consequences for patients. The present study aimed to investigate the quality of hemovigilance process in Iran, using the first two steps of Six Sigma model.
This was a quantitative cross-sectional study that was conducted over 6 months (from August 20, 2021, to February 20, 2022) at Afzalipour Hospital in Iran, using the first two steps of Six Sigma model. The study population comprised of all inpatients who needed blood or blood product transfusion in various departments of Afzalipour Hospital, among whom 477 patients were selected via stratified sampling in three shifts (morning, evening, and night). The datasheet was used to record errors in the three shifts. This research was conducted, using the DMAIC cycle's "define" and "measure" steps.
In the define step, the hemovigilance process at Afzalipour Hospital was divided into two categories of normal process and emergency process. Each of these processes consists of several sub-processes, including "phlebotomy," "requesting blood and blood products from the department," "preparation of application by the blood bank," " sending a request from the blood bank to the blood transfusion center," "transfusing blood and blood products," and "returning the blood and blood products to the blood bank and waste disposal." In the measure step, the quality of hemovigilance process was evaluated based on sub-processes and labels at morning, evening and night shifts. The sub-process of sending a request from the blood bank to the blood transfusion center had the highest error rate with a sigma level of 1.5. Also, the evening and night shifts had a sigma level of 1.875, and the clinical and registration labels had a sigma level of 1.875. The overall sigma level of hemovigilance process was calculated to be 2.
The results of this study showed that the quality of hemovigilance process at Afzalipour Hospital was poor. By employing the first two steps of Six Sigma method, we identified the existing errors in the hemovigilance process of Afzalipour hospital in order to assist hospital managers to take the necessary measures to improve this process.
血液警戒是一套涵盖从采集血液和血液制品到监测血液受者的输血链的监测方法。为此,该过程中的任何错误都可能给患者带来严重且不可挽回的后果。本研究旨在使用六西格玛模型的前两个步骤调查伊朗血液警戒过程的质量。
这是一项定量的横断面研究,于 2021 年 8 月 20 日至 2022 年 2 月 20 日在伊朗阿夫扎利波尔医院进行,使用六西格玛模型的前两个步骤。研究人群包括在阿夫扎利波尔医院各科室需要输血或血液制品的所有住院患者,其中通过分层抽样在三个班次(早班、晚班和夜班)中选择了 477 名患者。数据表用于记录三个班次的错误。本研究使用 DMAIC 循环的“定义”和“测量”步骤进行。
在定义步骤中,阿夫扎利波尔医院的血液警戒过程分为正常过程和紧急过程两类。每个过程都由几个子过程组成,包括“采血”、“从科室申请血液和血液制品”、“血液库准备申请”、“血液库向输血中心发送请求”、“输血和血液制品”以及“将血液和血液制品返回血液库和废物处理”。在测量步骤中,根据子过程和班次(早班、晚班和夜班)的标签评估血液警戒过程的质量。从血液库向输血中心发送请求的子过程错误率最高,西格玛水平为 1.5。此外,晚班和夜班的西格玛水平为 1.875,临床和注册标签的西格玛水平为 1.875。血液警戒过程的总体西格玛水平计算为 2。
本研究结果表明,阿夫扎利波尔医院血液警戒过程的质量较差。通过采用六西格玛方法的前两个步骤,我们确定了阿夫扎利波尔医院血液警戒过程中存在的错误,以便帮助医院管理者采取必要措施改进该过程。