Çarkaxhiu Bulut Gresa, Yorguner Nese
Department of Psychology, Galata University, Istanbul, Turkey.
Department of Psychiatry, Marmara University Medical School, Istanbul, Turkey.
Psychol Res Behav Manag. 2023 Oct 25;16:4315-4327. doi: 10.2147/PRBM.S437197. eCollection 2023.
Gender dysphoria (GD) emerged as a focal area in child and adolescent development research. While the intricacies of diagnosis and interventions for GD intertwine with diverse socio-cultural challenges, a notable dearth of knowledge exists about the experiences of transgender (TG) individuals during their formative years in Turkey. This study aims to unveil these experiences, shedding light on the challenges, perspectives, and implications in health care settings.
Our study encompassed 125 participants: 62 TGs under clinical follow-up, and a control group of 63 cisgender individuals. Surveys tailored to TG participants addressed early GD experiences, gender-typed activity participation, and psychosocial challenges from childhood through adolescence. Additionally, both cohorts contributed to a survey on attitudes towards community-based interventions, allowing for a comparative analysis of their perspectives.
TGs identified their GD around age 10.77. Female-to-male TGs showed more involvement in traditionally male-associated activities, whereas male-to-female engaged more in female-associated domestic role-plays (p<0.001). Over a third (37.09%) faced ostracization or bullying due to GD, 45.16% encountered verbal abuse, and 12.90% reported physical violence. Additionally, 40.32% had undergone treatment for depression and anxiety disorders. Most participants supported awareness initiatives, advocating for open gender expression, and normalizing the experiences of TG youth. Furthermore, 88.71% of TGs emphasized the importance of enhancing the expertise of professional groups, such as medical and mental health practitioners, in GD matters, a sentiment echoed by 68.25% of cisgender participants (p=0.030). While medical interventions were the least favored strategy at 32.80% overall, 46.78% of TGs supported it, compared to 19.05% of controls (p=0.010).
Our study underscores the challenges faced by TG individuals during development. Early recognition, societal awareness, enhanced training in professional healthcare environments, and comprehensive support are crucial for fostering acceptance and reducing adversity among children and adolescents navigating GD.
性别焦虑症(GD)已成为儿童和青少年发展研究的一个重点领域。虽然GD的诊断和干预的复杂性与各种社会文化挑战相互交织,但对于土耳其跨性别(TG)个体在其成长阶段的经历,存在明显的知识匮乏。本研究旨在揭示这些经历,阐明医疗保健环境中的挑战、观点及影响。
我们的研究包括125名参与者:62名接受临床随访的TG个体,以及一个由63名顺性别个体组成的对照组。针对TG参与者的调查问卷涉及早期GD经历、性别类型活动参与情况,以及从童年到青少年时期的心理社会挑战。此外,两个队列都参与了一项关于对基于社区干预措施态度的调查,以便对他们的观点进行比较分析。
TG个体在10.77岁左右识别出自己的GD。女性向男性转变的TG个体更多地参与传统上与男性相关的活动,而男性向女性转变的TG个体更多地参与与女性相关的家庭角色扮演(p<0.001)。超过三分之一(37.09%)的人因GD而面临排斥或欺凌,45.16%的人遭遇言语虐待,12.90%的人报告遭受身体暴力。此外,40.32%的人曾接受过抑郁症和焦虑症治疗。大多数参与者支持提高认识的举措,倡导开放的性别表达,并使TG青少年的经历正常化。此外,88.71%的TG个体强调提高专业群体(如医学和心理健康从业者)在GD问题上的专业知识的重要性,68.25%的顺性别参与者也表达了同样的观点(p=0.030)。虽然总体上医疗干预是最不受青睐的策略,占32.80%,但46.78%的TG个体支持它,而对照组中这一比例为19.05%(p=0.010)。
我们的研究强调了TG个体在发育过程中面临的挑战。早期识别、社会意识、专业医疗环境中强化培训以及全面支持对于促进对GD儿童和青少年的接纳并减少其困境至关重要。