Weidner Amanda, Ormsby Molly, Weinhold A J, Holmes John
WWAMI-Region Family Medicine Residency Network, Department of Family Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA.
Idaho State University Department of Family Medicine, Pocatello, ID.
J Med Educ Curric Dev. 2023 Nov 5;10:23821205231211198. doi: 10.1177/23821205231211198. eCollection 2023 Jan-Dec.
Residency programs must gather and track data on the diversity of their applicants, interviewees, and matched residents as part of the process of checking for bias in the interview and rank process. As such, the aims of this study were (1) to provide data from a large, regional network of family medicine residencies on who is applying, interviewing, and matching into our programs as a baseline for the family medicine residency community; and (2) to assess potential differences in the gender and racial diversity of the eligible applicants to programs across settings, including in rural and underserved communities.
Survey of programs in Alaska, Idaho, Montana, Washington and Wyoming about their applicant pool in the 2020-2021 interview season.
Programs received a median of 100 applications per position, 57 of which were considered eligible. Programs offered 17 interviews per position and 15 of these were completed. Programs in rural and underserved communities did not have fewer eligible applicants per position, nor was there less diversity within that pool of applicants. Most programs are working to increase their program's diversity.
On average, the racial and gender diversity of eligible applicants to programs in rural and underserved settings is no different than other programs. What is important in terms of diversity varies across programs, based on community needs and program mission, but having a mechanism to extract and review data and to then be able to assess progress is a place to start.
住院医师培训项目必须收集并跟踪其申请人、面试者以及匹配成功的住院医师的多样性数据,以此作为检查面试和排名过程中是否存在偏见的一部分。因此,本研究的目的是:(1)提供来自一个大型区域家庭医学住院医师培训网络的数据,内容涉及哪些人申请、参加面试并成功匹配到我们的项目中,作为家庭医学住院医师培训群体的基线数据;(2)评估不同环境下,包括农村和服务欠缺社区的项目,其合格申请人在性别和种族多样性方面的潜在差异。
对阿拉斯加、爱达荷州、蒙大拿州、华盛顿州和怀俄明州的项目进行调查,了解其在2020 - 2021面试季的申请人情况。
每个职位收到的申请中位数为100份,其中57份被视为合格。每个职位提供17次面试,其中15次面试完成。农村和服务欠缺社区的项目每个职位的合格申请人数量并不少,申请人群体中的多样性也并不低。大多数项目都在努力提高其项目的多样性。
平均而言,农村和服务欠缺地区项目的合格申请人在种族和性别多样性方面与其他项目没有差异。在多样性方面,重要的内容因项目而异,取决于社区需求和项目使命,但拥有一种提取和审查数据并进而能够评估进展的机制是一个良好的开端。