Borge Tiril C, Muller Ashley E
Folkehelseinstituttet, Oslo, Norway.
Nordisk Alkohol Nark. 2023 Oct;40(5):443-462. doi: 10.1177/14550725221143180. Epub 2023 Sep 6.
The Norwegian Directorate of Health is considering a national overdose warning system (OWS), to quickly alert users about substances with high overdose risks. Such a system would combine early detection of increased overdose risk and rapid notification to those at-risk. We conducted a systematic scoping review of research on existing OWSes. Aim 1 was to map current quantitative research on the effect of an OWS (number of users warned, number of overdoses, and notification speed). Aim 2 was to map qualitative research on users’ experiences. We used several machine learning functions to identify and assess 4102 references retrieved. Eleven studies met our inclusion criteria. The effect of OWSs on the number of overdoses was not possible to distinguish from the effect of existing overdose prevention measures. OWSs notified harm reduction groups or peer recovery support specialists as early as four hours after an increased risk was discovered. The number of users notified was largely unreported, most likely because data on this was not collected. From seven qualitative studies, patterns were identified across the main findings, related to preferences for language use and content, where notifications should come from, and the principles behind them. The evidence base, particularly relating to the effect of OWSs, is scarce. Without a sufficient knowledge base on effectiveness, we must be careful about making conclusions about which types of OWSs that should and should not be introduced in Norway. It can be viewed as a positive that the OWSs described in the included studies were heterogeneous. Creating an OWS does not necessarily have to involve the establishment of a new infrastructure, but rather links together well-developed, existing systems for monitoring and for harm reduction.
挪威卫生局正在考虑建立一个全国性的过量用药预警系统(OWS),以便迅速向使用者通报存在高过量用药风险的物质。这样一个系统将把过量用药风险增加的早期检测与向高危人群的快速通报结合起来。我们对现有过量用药预警系统的研究进行了系统的范围界定审查。目标1是梳理关于过量用药预警系统效果的当前定量研究(被警告的使用者数量、过量用药次数和通报速度)。目标2是梳理关于使用者体验的定性研究。我们使用了多种机器学习功能来识别和评估检索到的4102篇参考文献。11项研究符合我们的纳入标准。无法将过量用药预警系统对过量用药次数的影响与现有过量用药预防措施的影响区分开来。过量用药预警系统在发现风险增加后最早4小时就通知了减少伤害组织或同伴康复支持专家。被通知的使用者数量大多未报告,很可能是因为未收集这方面的数据。从7项定性研究中,在主要发现中识别出了一些模式,这些模式与语言使用和内容偏好、通知应该来自何处以及背后的原则有关。证据基础,特别是与过量用药预警系统效果相关的证据基础很匮乏。在没有关于有效性的充分知识库的情况下,我们在就挪威应该和不应该引入哪种类型的过量用药预警系统得出结论时必须谨慎。纳入研究中描述的过量用药预警系统具有异质性,这可以被视为一个积极的方面。创建一个过量用药预警系统不一定非要建立新的基础设施,而是可以将现有的完善的监测和减少伤害系统联系起来。