Biradar Kashiroygoud, Deepthi Sangineedi, Kumar Sanjay, Singh Roohie, Dutta Angshuman
Dept of ENT & HNS, Command Hospital Air Force, Bangalore Agaram Post, Old Airport Road, Bangalore, 560007 India.
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2023 Dec;75(4):3211-3215. doi: 10.1007/s12070-023-03979-9. Epub 2023 Jun 16.
Adenoidectomy is most commonly performed in children to alleviate the symptoms pertaining to adenoid hypertrophy. The conventional cold steel method utilizing adenoid curette is the most commonly performed method in the world even after the invention of endoscopes & powered instruments like coblator & microdebrider due to the cost & time factors. The conventional method being a blind procedure, carries higher rate of recurrence due to remnant tissues. The visualization of the adenoid tissue in nasopharynx through the nasal endoscope helps in better engagement of adenoids into the curette & adequate tissue clearance with reduced recurrence of symptoms.
To study the effect of visualization of adenoid tissue for better tissue clearance in conventional adenoidectomy.
To compare the duration of surgery, blood loss & recurrence rate following conventional cold steel adenoidectomy (CSA) & endoscope assisted cold steel adenoidectomy (EACSA).
50 patients who underwent adenoidectomy with various indications were grouped into two groups with 25 patients each. Group A underwent (CSA)with or without tonsillectomy & Group B underwent (EACSA) with or without tonsillectomy were followed up for the duration of 3 months. The patients were evaluated for duration of surgery & post operatively for the recurrence at 3rd month of follow up.
In our study, it was found that the tissue clearance in Group A was significantly low. The recurrence rate of 48% was observed in CSA group compared to 0% in group B with EACSA. The duration of surgery in both the procedures were comparable.
EACSA is an effective modification to CSA. It adds the benefits of endoscopic visualization of adenoid for the conventional curettage. The high recurrence rates of CA can be effectively reduced with no significant variation in duration of surgery.
腺样体切除术在儿童中最为常见,用于缓解与腺样体肥大相关的症状。尽管已经发明了内窥镜以及诸如低温等离子刀和微型切割器等动力器械,但由于成本和时间因素,使用腺样体刮匙的传统冷钢方法仍是世界上最常用的方法。传统方法是一种盲目操作,由于残留组织,复发率较高。通过鼻内窥镜观察鼻咽部的腺样体组织有助于更好地将腺样体放入刮匙,并实现充分的组织清除,从而降低症状复发率。
研究在传统腺样体切除术中,观察腺样体组织对更好地清除组织的效果。
比较传统冷钢腺样体切除术(CSA)和内窥镜辅助冷钢腺样体切除术(EACSA)后的手术时间、失血量和复发率。
50例因各种适应证接受腺样体切除术的患者被分为两组,每组25例。A组接受CSA(有或无扁桃体切除术),B组接受EACSA(有或无扁桃体切除术),随访3个月。评估患者的手术时间,并在随访的第3个月对术后复发情况进行评估。
在我们的研究中,发现A组的组织清除率明显较低。CSA组的复发率为48%,而EACSA组的B组为0%。两种手术的手术时间相当。
EACSA是对CSA的有效改进。它为传统刮除术增加了内窥镜观察腺样体的优点。可以有效降低CSA的高复发率,且手术时间无明显差异。