Mertens Stien, Verbraeken Lennart, Sprenger Heike, De Meyer Sam, Demuynck Kirin, Cannoot Bernard, Merchie Julie, De Block Jolien, Vogel Jonathan T, Bruce Wesley, Nelissen Hilde, Maere Steven, Inzé Dirk, Wuyts Nathalie
Department of Plant Biotechnology and Bioinformatics, Ghent University, Technologiepark 71, 9052, Zwijnaarde, Belgium.
VIB Center for Plant Systems Biology, Technologiepark 71, 9052, Zwijnaarde, Belgium.
Plant Methods. 2023 Nov 23;19(1):132. doi: 10.1186/s13007-023-01102-1.
Thermography is a popular tool to assess plant water-use behavior, as plant temperature is influenced by transpiration rate, and is commonly used in field experiments to detect plant water deficit. Its application in indoor automated phenotyping platforms is still limited and mainly focuses on differences in plant temperature between genotypes or treatments, instead of estimating stomatal conductance or transpiration rate. In this study, the transferability of commonly used thermography analysis protocols from the field to greenhouse phenotyping platforms was evaluated. In addition, the added value of combining thermal infrared (TIR) with hyperspectral imaging to monitor drought effects on plant transpiration rate (E) was evaluated.
The sensitivity of commonly used TIR indices to detect drought-induced and genotypic differences in water status was investigated in eight maize inbred lines in the automated phenotyping platform PHENOVISION. Indices that normalized plant temperature for vapor pressure deficit and/or air temperature at the time of imaging were most sensitive to drought and could detect genotypic differences in the plants' water-use behavior. However, these indices were not strongly correlated to stomatal conductance and E. The canopy temperature depression index, the crop water stress index and the simplified stomatal conductance index were more suitable to monitor these traits, and were consequently used to develop empirical E prediction models by combining them with hyperspectral indices and/or environmental variables. Different modeling strategies were evaluated, including single index-based, machine learning and mechanistic models. Model comparison showed that combining multiple TIR indices in a random forest model can improve E prediction accuracy, and that the contribution of the hyperspectral data is limited when multiple indices are used. However, the empirical models trained on one genotype were not transferable to all eight inbred lines.
Overall, this study demonstrates that existing TIR indices can be used to monitor drought stress and develop E prediction models in an indoor setup, as long as the indices normalize plant temperature for ambient air temperature or relative humidity.
热成像技术是评估植物水分利用行为的常用工具,因为植物温度受蒸腾速率影响,常用于田间试验以检测植物水分亏缺。其在室内自动表型分析平台中的应用仍然有限,主要集中在不同基因型或处理之间植物温度的差异,而非估计气孔导度或蒸腾速率。在本研究中,评估了常用热成像分析协议从田间到温室表型分析平台的可转移性。此外,还评估了将热红外(TIR)与高光谱成像相结合以监测干旱对植物蒸腾速率(E)影响的附加价值。
在自动表型分析平台PHENOVISION中,对八个玉米自交系研究了常用TIR指数检测干旱诱导和基因型水分状况差异的敏感性。针对成像时的蒸汽压亏缺和/或气温对植物温度进行归一化的指数对干旱最为敏感,能够检测植物水分利用行为的基因型差异。然而,这些指数与气孔导度和E的相关性不强。冠层温度降低指数、作物水分胁迫指数和简化气孔导度指数更适合监测这些性状,因此将它们与高光谱指数和/或环境变量相结合,用于开发经验性E预测模型。评估了不同的建模策略,包括基于单一指数的模型、机器学习模型和机理模型。模型比较表明,在随机森林模型中组合多个TIR指数可以提高E预测精度,并且当使用多个指数时,高光谱数据的贡献有限。然而,在一个基因型上训练的经验模型不能转移到所有八个自交系。
总体而言,本研究表明,只要指数针对环境空气温度或相对湿度对植物温度进行归一化,现有的TIR指数就可用于在室内设置中监测干旱胁迫并开发E预测模型。