Cai Jiaxin, Hu Weiwei, Ma Jiaojiao, Si Aima, Chen Shiyu, Gong Lingmin, Zhang Yong, Yan Hong, Chen Fangyao
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, Xi'an Jiaotong University, Xi'an 710061, China.
Department of Neurology, Xi'an Gaoxin Hospital, Xi'an 710077, China.
Brain Sci. 2023 Oct 31;13(11):1535. doi: 10.3390/brainsci13111535.
Predicting cognition decline in patients with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is crucial for identifying high-risk individuals and implementing effective management. To improve predicting MCI-to-AD conversion, it is necessary to consider various factors using explainable machine learning (XAI) models which provide interpretability while maintaining predictive accuracy. This study used the Explainable Boosting Machine (EBM) model with multimodal features to predict the conversion of MCI to AD during different follow-up periods while providing interpretability.
This retrospective case-control study is conducted with data obtained from the ADNI database, with records of 1042 MCI patients from 2006 to 2022 included. The exposures included in this study were MRI biomarkers, cognitive scores, demographics, and clinical features. The main outcome was AD conversion from aMCI during follow-up. The EBM model was utilized to predict aMCI converting to AD based on three feature combinations, obtaining interpretability while ensuring accuracy. Meanwhile, the interaction effect was considered in the model. The three feature combinations were compared in different follow-up periods with accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and AUC-ROC. The global and local explanations are displayed by importance ranking and feature interpretability plots.
The five-years prediction accuracy reached 85% (AUC = 0.92) using both cognitive scores and MRI markers. Apart from accuracies, we obtained features' importance in different follow-up periods. In early stage of AD, the MRI markers play a major role, while for middle-term, the cognitive scores are more important. Feature risk scoring plots demonstrated insightful nonlinear interactive associations between selected factors and outcome. In one-year prediction, lower right inferior temporal volume (<9000) is significantly associated with AD conversion. For two-year prediction, low left inferior temporal thickness (<2) is most critical. For three-year prediction, higher FAQ scores (>4) is the most important. During four-year prediction, APOE4 is the most critical. For five-year prediction, lower right entorhinal volume (<1000) is the most critical feature.
The established glass-box model EBMs with multimodal features demonstrated a superior ability with detailed interpretability in predicting AD conversion from MCI. Multi features with significant importance were identified. Further study may be of significance to determine whether the established prediction tool would improve clinical management for AD patients.
预测轻度认知障碍(MCI)患者的认知能力下降对于识别高危个体和实施有效管理至关重要。为了提高对MCI向阿尔茨海默病(AD)转化的预测能力,有必要使用可解释机器学习(XAI)模型来考虑各种因素,这些模型在保持预测准确性的同时提供可解释性。本研究使用具有多模态特征的可解释增强机器(EBM)模型来预测MCI在不同随访期向AD的转化,并提供可解释性。
本回顾性病例对照研究使用从阿尔茨海默病神经影像学倡议(ADNI)数据库获得的数据,纳入了2006年至2022年期间1042例MCI患者的记录。本研究纳入的暴露因素包括磁共振成像(MRI)生物标志物、认知评分、人口统计学和临床特征。主要结局是随访期间从轻度认知障碍(aMCI)转化为AD。EBM模型基于三种特征组合用于预测aMCI转化为AD,在确保准确性的同时获得可解释性。同时,在模型中考虑了交互作用。在不同随访期对这三种特征组合的准确性、敏感性、特异性和曲线下面积(AUC-ROC)进行了比较。通过重要性排名和特征可解释性图展示全局和局部解释。
使用认知评分和MRI标记物,五年预测准确率达到85%(AUC = 0.92)。除了准确率,我们还获得了不同随访期特征的重要性。在AD早期,MRI标记物起主要作用,而在中期,认知评分更重要。特征风险评分图显示了所选因素与结局之间有深刻见解的非线性交互关联。在一年预测中,右下颞叶体积较低(<9000)与AD转化显著相关。在两年预测中,左下颞叶厚度较低(<2)最为关键。在三年预测中,功能活动问卷(FAQ)评分较高(>4)是最重要的。在四年预测中,载脂蛋白E4(APOE4)最为关键。在五年预测中,右下内嗅皮质体积较低(<1000)是最关键的特征。
所建立的具有多模态特征的透明盒模型EBM在预测MCI向AD转化方面表现出卓越能力,并具有详细的可解释性。识别出了具有重要意义的多种特征。进一步研究确定所建立的预测工具是否能改善AD患者的临床管理可能具有重要意义。