Smith Shelby R, Hodakowski Alexander, McCormick Johnathon R, Spaan Jonathan, Streepy John, Mowers Colton, Simcock Xavier
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL.
J Hand Surg Glob Online. 2023 Aug 26;5(6):818-822. doi: 10.1016/j.jhsg.2023.07.015. eCollection 2023 Nov.
This study classifies common questions searched by patients from the Google search engine and categorizes the types and quality of online education resources used by patients regarding carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) and carpal tunnel release (CTR).
Google's results were extracted and compiled using the "People also ask" function for frequent questions and associated web pages for CTS and CTR. Questions were categorized using Rothwell's classification with further topic subcategorization. Web pages were evaluated by using Journal of the American Medical Association Benchmark Criteria for source quality.
Of the 600 questions evaluated, "How do I know if I have carpal tunnel or tendonitis?" and "What causes carpal tunnel to flare up?" were the most commonly investigated questions for CTS. For CTR, frequent questions investigated included "How long after hand surgery can I drive" and "How do you wipe after carpal tunnel surgery." The most common questions for CTS by Rothwell classification were policy (51%), fact (41%), and value (8%) with the highest subcategories being indications/management (46%) and technical details (27%). For CTR, the most common questions entailed fact (54%), policy (34%), and value (11%) with the highest subcategories as technical details (31%) and indications/management (26%). The most common web pages were academic and medical practice. The mean Journal of the American Medical Association score for all 600 web pages was 1.43, with journals (mean = 3.91) having the highest score and legal (mean = 0.52) and single surgeon practice websites (mean = 0.28) having the lowest scores.
Patients frequently inquire online about etiology, precipitating factors, diagnostic criteria, and activity restrictions regarding CTS/CTR. Overall, the quality of online resources for this topic was poor, especially from single surgeon practices and legal websites.
Understanding the type and quality of information patients are accessing assists physicians in tailoring counseling to patient concerns and facilitates informed decision-making regarding CTS/CTR as well as guiding patients to high-quality online searches.
本研究对患者在谷歌搜索引擎上搜索的常见问题进行分类,并对患者使用的关于腕管综合征(CTS)和腕管松解术(CTR)的在线教育资源的类型和质量进行分类。
利用谷歌的“人们也问”功能提取并整理关于CTS和CTR的常见问题及相关网页。问题采用罗斯韦尔分类法进行分类,并进一步细分主题。网页使用美国医学会基准标准对来源质量进行评估。
在评估的600个问题中,“我如何知道自己是患有腕管综合征还是肌腱炎?”以及“腕管综合征发作的原因是什么?”是关于CTS最常被调查的问题。对于CTR,经常被调查的问题包括“手部手术后多久我可以开车”以及“腕管手术后如何擦拭”。按照罗斯韦尔分类法,CTS最常见的问题是政策类(51%)、事实类(41%)和价值观类(8%),其中最高的子类别是适应症/管理类(46%)和技术细节类(27%)。对于CTR,最常见的问题是事实类(54%)、政策类(34%)和价值观类(11%),其中最高的子类别是技术细节类(31%)和适应症/管理类(26%)。最常见的网页是学术和医疗实践类。所有600个网页的美国医学会平均得分是1.43,期刊(平均 = 3.91)得分最高,法律类(平均 = 0.52)和单外科医生执业网站(平均 = 0.28)得分最低。
患者经常在网上询问关于CTS/CTR的病因、诱发因素、诊断标准和活动限制。总体而言,该主题的在线资源质量较差,尤其是来自单外科医生执业网站和法律网站的资源。
了解患者获取的信息类型和质量有助于医生根据患者的关注点调整咨询内容,并促进关于CTS/CTR的明智决策,同时指导患者进行高质量的在线搜索。