Tsranchev Ivan I, Mileva Biliana, Goshev Metodi, Timonov Pavel, Spasov Svetlozar, Alexandrov Alexandar
Department of Forensic Medicine and Deontology, Medical University of Plovdiv, Plovdiv, BGR.
Department of Forensic Medicine and Deontology, Medical University of Sofia, Sofia, BGR.
Cureus. 2023 Nov 28;15(11):e49615. doi: 10.7759/cureus.49615. eCollection 2023 Nov.
With the development of human society, the question of the value and inviolability of human life begins to occupy a central place in the various social strata and social structures. With the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights after the Second World War, the basic postulates protecting the right to inviolability of human life were laid. The question focused on euthanasia has been discussed in several European countries, such as Germany, Ireland, France, and Italy, leading to considerable interest in the medical community in Bulgaria.
A prospective study was performed using approved sample cards, analyzing the general knowledge of the medical community in the Republic of Bulgaria about euthanasia and assisted suicide over a period of four months, between January 2023 and May 2023. In this process, 623 people were surveyed, and the questionnaire included several targeted questions through electronically generated samples on the Microsoft Forms platform. The target group had doctors with and without a specialty in various fields of hospital and pre-hospital care, dentists, and students from the fields of medicine and dentistry.
The results show that the majority of medical professionals clearly state their positive opinion on the adoption of a law to legalize euthanasia in the Republic of Bulgaria, clearly taking into account the fact that the right to life has always been and always will be the most absolute and fundamental human right. Contrary to the above, it is implied that it is inevitably linked to a quality and fulfilling life without suffering. Identically, they also answered that a person should have the right to know exactly when to end his own life. The medical society in Bulgaria clearly shows its positive opinion regarding the idea that the different forms of euthanasia (active euthanasia and assisted suicide) should be defined as morally and legally permissible. Our research confirms the Bulgarian medical community's opinion that the subject of the problems of euthanasia and its legal regulation are already ripe for public discussion, similar to many other European countries.
The actual issue of euthanasia as a conclusion raises several questions related to the process of acceptance of standard algorithms for action in such cases where the same action is legalized by law. It also includes the process of acceptance of strict regulations by the countries for the so-called negative phenomenon "death tourism" and several other administrative actions related to the mandatory registration of every case of euthanasia, the implementation of mandatory consultations with a psychiatrist and psychologist for patients seeking euthanasia as the only possible option, and providing possible alternatives regarding their illness. This is the unchangeable cornerstone for standardizing the legalization process and acceptance of "good death" in Bulgaria. In its essence, euthanasia creates both a social and an ethical conflict in our modern society, appearing at the same time as a kind of "stress test" for the health system.
随着人类社会的发展,人类生命的价值和不可侵犯性问题开始在各个社会阶层和社会结构中占据核心地位。第二次世界大战后通过了《世界人权宣言》,奠定了保护人类生命不可侵犯权的基本假设。在德国、爱尔兰、法国和意大利等几个欧洲国家,围绕安乐死问题展开了讨论,这在保加利亚医学界引发了相当大的兴趣。
采用经批准的样本卡进行前瞻性研究,分析2023年1月至2023年5月这四个月期间保加利亚共和国医学界对安乐死和协助自杀的一般认知。在此过程中,对623人进行了调查,问卷通过微软表单平台上的电子生成样本包含了几个针对性问题。目标群体包括医院和院前护理各领域有专业和无专业的医生、牙医以及医学和牙医学领域的学生。
结果表明,大多数医学专业人员明确表示支持在保加利亚共和国通过一项将安乐死合法化的法律,同时明确考虑到生命权一直是且将永远是最绝对和基本的人权这一事实。与此相反,这意味着它不可避免地与高质量且无痛苦的充实生活相关联。同样,他们还回答说,一个人应该有权确切知道何时结束自己的生命。保加利亚医学界明确表示支持这样一种观点,即不同形式的安乐死(主动安乐死和协助自杀)应在道德和法律上被视为可允许的。我们的研究证实了保加利亚医学界的观点,即安乐死问题及其法律规范已经成熟,可以像许多其他欧洲国家一样进行公开讨论。
作为结论,安乐死的实际问题引发了几个与在法律将同一行为合法化的情况下接受标准行动算法的过程相关的问题。它还包括各国接受对所谓“死亡旅游”这一负面现象的严格监管以及与每例安乐死强制登记、为寻求安乐死作为唯一可能选择的患者强制安排精神科医生和心理学家会诊以及提供关于其疾病的可能替代方案等若干其他行政行动的过程。这是保加利亚规范合法化过程和接受“善终”的不变基石。从本质上讲,安乐死在我们现代社会中既引发了社会冲突,也引发了伦理冲突,同时它也是对卫生系统的一种“压力测试”。