Li Lian-Shuo, Luo Xiao-Juan, Shu Xin-Peng, Li Zi-Wei, Liu Fei, Liu Xu-Rui, Tong Yue, Lv Quan, Liu Xiao-Yu, Zhang Wei, Peng Dong
Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery The First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University Chongqing China.
Department of Endoscopy Center The First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University Chongqing China.
JGH Open. 2023 Nov 20;7(12):936-941. doi: 10.1002/jgh3.13005. eCollection 2023 Dec.
The aim of this study was to assess the quality and content of videos on Douyin and TikTok for their educational role on early screening of rectal cancer (RC).
We conducted a search for videos related to RC on the Douyin and TikTok applications on 20 April 2023. The search was conducted in Chinese on Douyin and in English and Japanese on TikTok. A sample of the first 100 videos recommended by the software was selected for each language group. The content of the videos was evaluated using a content scorecard, while the quality of the videos was assessed using DISCERN. Subsequently, we conducted two partial correlations: one between the DISCERN score and the number of likes, and another between the video content score and the number of likes.
This study encompassed a total of 89 Chinese, 54 English, and 51 Japanese videos. After selection, 78 Chinese, 38 English, and 25 Japanese videos were identified to contain content related to early screening for RC, prompting further quality assessment. Notably, videos in the Chinese language showed the highest DISCERN score ( < 0.05). In terms of partial correlation analysis, it was observed that both the content score and DISCERN score did not show a significant correlation with the number of likes ( > 0.05).
In terms of quality score and content score, the Chinese videos on Douyin show superiority over the English and Japanese videos on TikTok. However, there is potential for improving the overall appeal of the Chinese videos.
本研究旨在评估抖音和TikTok上关于直肠癌早期筛查教育作用的视频质量和内容。
2023年4月20日,我们在抖音和TikTok应用程序上搜索与直肠癌相关的视频。在抖音上用中文搜索,在TikTok上用英文和日文搜索。为每个语言组选取软件推荐的前100个视频样本。使用内容记分卡评估视频内容,同时使用DISCERN评估视频质量。随后,我们进行了两个偏相关性分析:一个是DISCERN评分与点赞数之间的分析,另一个是视频内容评分与点赞数之间的分析。
本研究共纳入89个中文视频、54个英文视频和51个日文视频。筛选后,确定78个中文视频、38个英文视频和25个日文视频包含与直肠癌早期筛查相关的内容,促使进行进一步的质量评估。值得注意的是,中文视频的DISCERN评分最高(<0.05)。在偏相关性分析方面,观察到内容评分和DISCERN评分与点赞数均无显著相关性(>0.05)。
在质量评分和内容评分方面,抖音上的中文视频比TikTok上的英文和日文视频更具优势。然而,中文视频的整体吸引力仍有提升空间。