Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Department of Continuing Professional Development and Division of Medical Education at Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Perspect Med Educ. 2023 Dec 29;12(1):594-602. doi: 10.5334/pme.1035. eCollection 2023.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, medical schools were forced to suspend in-person interviews and transition to a virtual Multiple Mini Interview (vMMI) format. MMIs typically comprise multiple short assessments overseen by assessors, with the aim of measuring a wide range of non-cognitive competencies. The adaptation to vMMI required medical schools to make swift changes to their MMI structure and delivery. In this paper, we focus on two specific groups greatly impacted by the decision to transition to vMMIs: medical school applicants and MMI assessors.
We conducted an interpretive qualitative study to explore medical school applicants' and assessors' experiences transitioning to an asynchronous vMMI format. Ten assessors and five medical students from one Canadian medical school participated in semi-structured interviews. Data was analyzed using a thematic analysis framework.
Both applicants and assessors shared a mutual feeling of longing and nostalgia for an interview experience that, due to the pandemic, was understandably adapted. The most obvious forms of loss experienced - albeit in different ways - were: 1) human connection and 2) missed opportunity. Applicants and assessors described several factors that amplified their grief/loss response. These were: 1) resource availability, 2) technological concerns, and 3) the virtual interview environment.
While virtual interviewing has obvious advantages, we cannot overlook that asynchronous vMMIs do not lend themselves to the same caliber of interaction and camaraderie as experienced in in-person interviews. We outline several recommendations medical schools can implement to enhance the vMMI experience for applicants and assessors.
在 COVID-19 大流行期间,医学院被迫暂停面谈及转为虚拟多站式迷你面试(vMMI)模式。MMI 通常由多名评估员监督的多个简短评估组成,旨在衡量广泛的非认知能力。向 vMMI 的转变要求医学院迅速改变其 MMI 结构和交付方式。在本文中,我们重点关注受向 vMMI 过渡决策影响最大的两个特定群体:医学院申请人和 MMI 评估员。
我们进行了一项解释性定性研究,以探讨医学院申请人和评估员在过渡到异步 vMMI 格式时的经验。来自加拿大一所医学院的 10 名评估员和 5 名医学生参加了半结构化访谈。使用主题分析框架对数据进行分析。
申请人和评估员都对因疫情而不得不适应的面试体验表示怀念和留恋。他们经历的最明显的损失形式是:1)人际联系和 2)错失的机会。申请人和评估员描述了几种放大他们悲伤/失落反应的因素。这些因素是:1)资源可用性,2)技术问题,以及 3)虚拟面试环境。
虽然虚拟面试有明显的优势,但我们不能忽视异步 vMMI 无法提供与亲身面试相同的互动和友谊体验。我们概述了医学院可以实施的一些建议,以增强申请人和评估员对 vMMI 的体验。