Buchman Aron S
Rush Alzheimer's Disease Center, Department of Neurological Sciences, Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, Illinois.
Curr Opin Behav Sci. 2024 Feb;55. doi: 10.1016/j.cobeha.2023.101345. Epub 2024 Jan 6.
Medical innovation and technologic advances enrich daily living and occur within our normative worlds, that are socially constructed. These advances confront society with critical questions about the nature of human life, laying bare the inadequacies of extant norms and boundaries. Yet, society has been unable to develop consensus about when life ends. Scientific studies highlight that life is best characterized by continua without natural boundaries. Thus, scientific information alone cannot be employed to justify the socially constructed health categories required for setting norms and boundaries. An iterative process that integrates a broad range of non-scientific data with advancing scientific information is needed to facilitate consensus for updating social norms and boundaries. This can lead to a new taxonomy of living across the measurable continuum of life and align our normative worlds with the dizzying pace of medical innovation and advances in technologies transforming the world in which we live.
医学创新和技术进步丰富了日常生活,且发生在我们社会建构的规范世界之中。这些进步使社会面临有关人类生命本质的关键问题,暴露出现有规范和界限的不足之处。然而,社会在生命何时结束的问题上未能达成共识。科学研究表明,生命的最佳特征是没有自然界限的连续体。因此,仅靠科学信息无法用来为设定规范和界限所需的社会建构的健康类别提供正当理由。需要一个迭代过程,将广泛的非科学数据与不断发展的科学信息相结合,以促进就更新社会规范和界限达成共识。这可以带来一种跨越可测量生命连续体的新生命分类法,并使我们的规范世界与改变我们生活世界的医学创新和技术进步的惊人速度保持一致。