Zhu Ke-Xin, Wu Min, Bian Zhi-Lin, Han Shi-Liang, Fang Li-Ming, Ge Feng-Feng, Wang Xue-Zhou, Xie Sheng-Fang
Affiliated Hospital of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, Nanjing University of Chinese Medicine, Nanjing, China.
Jiangsu Province Academy of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Nanjing, China.
Front Pharmacol. 2024 Feb 1;15:1293468. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2024.1293468. eCollection 2024.
Despite the clinical value of Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), restricted comprehension of its toxicity limits the secure and efficacious application. Previous studies primarily focused on exploring specific toxicities within CHM, without providing an overview of CHM's toxicity. The absence of a quantitative assessment of focal points renders the future research trajectory ambiguous. Therefore, this study aimed to reveal research trends and areas of concern for the past decade. A cross-sectional study was conducted on publications related to CHM and toxicity over the past decade from Web of Science Core Collection database. The characteristics of the publication included publication year, journal, institution, funding, keywords, and citation counts were recorded. Co-occurrence analysis and trend topic analysis based on bibliometric analysis were conducted on keywords and citations. A total of 3,225 publications were analyzed. Number of annal publications increased over the years, with the highest number observed in 2022 (n = 475). The published the most publications (n = 425). The most frequently used toxicity classifications in keywords were hepatotoxicity (n = 119) or drug-induced liver injury (n = 48), and nephrotoxicity (n = 40). Co-occurrence analysis revealed relatively loose connections between CHM and toxicity, and their derivatives. Keywords emerging from trend topic analysis for the past 3 years (2019-2022) included ferroptosis, NLRP3 inflammasome, machine learning, network pharmacology, traditional uses, and pharmacology. Concerns about the toxicity of CHM have increased in the past decade. However, there remains insufficient studies that directly explore the intersection of CHM and toxicity. Hepatotoxicity and nephrotoxicity, as the most concerned toxicity classifications associated with CHM, warrant more in-depth investigations. Apoptosis was the most concerned toxicological mechanism. As a recent increase in attention, exploring the mechanisms of ferroptosis in nephrotoxicity and NLRP3 inflammasome in hepatotoxicity could provide valuable insights. Machine learning and network pharmacology are potential methods for future studies.
尽管中草药具有临床价值,但其毒性方面的认知受限,限制了其安全有效的应用。以往研究主要聚焦于探究中草药内的特定毒性,未对其毒性进行全面概述。缺乏对重点的定量评估使得未来研究方向不明确。因此,本研究旨在揭示过去十年的研究趋势及关注领域。对过去十年来自科学网核心合集数据库中与中草药和毒性相关的出版物进行了横断面研究。记录了出版物的特征,包括出版年份、期刊、机构、资金、关键词和被引次数。基于文献计量分析对关键词和引文进行了共现分析和趋势主题分析。共分析了3225篇出版物。年度出版物数量逐年增加,2022年数量最多(n = 475)。发表出版物最多的是(n = 425)。关键词中最常使用的毒性分类是肝毒性(n = 119)或药物性肝损伤(n = 48)以及肾毒性(n = 40)。共现分析揭示了中草药与其毒性及其衍生物之间的联系相对松散。过去三年(2019 - 2022年)趋势主题分析中出现的关键词包括铁死亡、NLRP3炎性小体、机器学习、网络药理学、传统用途和药理学。在过去十年中,对中草药毒性的关注有所增加。然而,直接探索中草药与毒性交叉点的研究仍然不足。肝毒性和肾毒性作为与中草药相关的最受关注的毒性分类,值得更深入研究。细胞凋亡是最受关注的毒理学机制。作为最近关注度增加的方面,探索肾毒性中的铁死亡机制和肝毒性中的NLRP3炎性小体机制可能会提供有价值的见解。机器学习和网络药理学是未来研究的潜在方法。