South West Critical Thinking Unit, Health Care Public Health Directorate, NHS England, Bristol, United Kingdom.
Public Health Intelligence Team, Devon County Council, Exeter, England.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Feb 22;24(1):561. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-17940-0.
In the UK, unique and unforeseen factors, including COVID-19, Brexit, and Ukraine-Russia war, have resulted in an unprecedented cost of living crisis, creating a second health emergency. We present, one of the first rapid reviews with the aim of examining the impact of this current crisis, at a population level. We reviewed published literature, as well as grey literature, examining a broad range of physical and mental impacts on health in the short, mid, and long term, identifying those most at risk, impacts on system partners, including emergency services and the third sector, as well as mitigation strategies.
We conducted a rapid review by searching PubMed, Embase, MEDLINE, and HMIC (2020 to 2023). We searched for grey literature on Google and hand-searched the reports of relevant public health organisations. We included interventional and observational studies that reported outcomes of interventions aimed at mitigating against the impacts of cost of living at a population level.
We found that the strongest evidence was for the impact of cold and mouldy homes on respiratory-related infections and respiratory conditions. Those at an increased risk were young children (0-4 years), the elderly (aged 75 and over), as well as those already vulnerable, including those with long-term multimorbidity. Further short-term impacts include an increased risk of physical pain including musculoskeletal and chest pain, and increased risk of enteric infections and malnutrition. In the mid-term, we could see increases in hypertension, transient ischaemic attacks, and myocardial infarctions, and respiratory illnesses. In the long term we could see an increase in mortality and morbidity rates from respiratory and cardiovascular disease, as well as increase rates of suicide and self-harm and infectious disease outcomes. Changes in behaviour are likely particularly around changes in food buying patterns and the ability to heat a home. System partners are also impacted, with voluntary sectors seeing fewer volunteers, an increase in petty crime and theft, alternative heating appliances causing fires, and an increase in burns and burn-related admissions. To mitigate against these impacts, support should be provided, to the most vulnerable, to help increase disposable income, reduce energy bills, and encourage home improvements linked with energy efficiency. Stronger links to bridge voluntary, community, charity and faith groups are needed to help provide additional aid and support.
Although the CoL crisis affects the entire population, the impacts are exacerbated in those that are most vulnerable, particularly young children, single parents, multigenerational families. More can be done at a community and societal level to support the most vulnerable, and those living with long-term multimorbidity. This review consolidates the current evidence on the impacts of the cost of living crisis and may enable decision makers to target limited resources more effectively.
在英国,新冠疫情、英国脱欧和俄乌战争等独特且意料之外的因素导致生活成本危机达到前所未有的程度,形成了第二次卫生紧急情况。我们呈现了首批快速审查之一,旨在从人群层面研究当前危机的影响。我们查阅了已发表的文献和灰色文献,研究了短期、中期和长期内对健康的各种身心影响,确定了风险最高的人群,以及对包括紧急服务和第三部门在内的系统合作伙伴的影响,以及缓解策略。
我们通过搜索 PubMed、Embase、MEDLINE 和 HMIC(2020 年至 2023 年)进行了快速审查。我们在 Google 上搜索灰色文献,并手动搜索相关公共卫生组织的报告。我们纳入了旨在缓解人群层面生活成本影响的干预措施的结果的干预和观察性研究。
我们发现,最强有力的证据是寒冷和潮湿房屋对呼吸道相关感染和呼吸道疾病的影响。风险较高的人群是幼儿(0-4 岁)、老年人(75 岁及以上)以及已经脆弱的人群,包括患有长期多种疾病的人群。进一步的短期影响包括身体疼痛(包括肌肉骨骼和胸痛)风险增加,以及肠内感染和营养不良风险增加。中期,我们可能会看到高血压、短暂性脑缺血发作和心肌梗死以及呼吸道疾病的发病率增加。长期来看,我们可能会看到呼吸道和心血管疾病的死亡率和发病率增加,以及自杀和自残以及传染病结果的发病率增加。行为的变化可能特别围绕着购买食物模式和家庭供暖能力的变化。系统合作伙伴也受到影响,志愿部门的志愿者减少,轻微犯罪和盗窃增加,替代供暖设备引起火灾,烧伤和烧伤相关入院人数增加。为了缓解这些影响,应该向最脆弱的人群提供支持,以增加可支配收入,降低能源账单,并鼓励与能源效率相关的家庭改善。需要与志愿、社区、慈善和宗教团体建立更强的联系,以提供额外的援助和支持。
尽管生活成本危机影响到整个人口,但对最脆弱的人群(特别是幼儿、单亲父母和多代家庭)的影响更为严重。在社区和社会层面可以做更多的工作来支持最脆弱的人群和患有长期多种疾病的人群。本综述整合了当前关于生活成本危机影响的证据,这可能使决策者能够更有效地针对有限的资源。