School of Media & Communication, Sunmoon University, Chungcheongnam-do, Republic of Korea.
Home Visit Healthcare Team, Expert Group on Health Promotion for Seoul Metropolitan Government, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Mar 19;26:e50518. doi: 10.2196/50518.
In recent years, Korean society has increasingly recognized the importance of nurses in the context of population aging and infectious disease control. However, nurses still face difficulties with regard to policy activities that are aimed at improving the nursing workforce structure and working environment. Media coverage plays an important role in public awareness of a particular issue and can be an important strategy in policy activities.
This study analyzed data from 18 years of news coverage on nursing-related issues. The focus of this study was to examine the drivers of the social, local, economic, and political agendas that were emphasized in the media by the analysis of main sources and their quotes. This analysis revealed which nursing media agendas were emphasized (eg, social aspects), neglected (eg, policy aspects), and negotiated.
Descriptive analysis, natural language processing, and semantic network analysis were applied to analyze data collected from 2005 to 2022. BigKinds were used for the collection of data, automatic multi-categorization of news, named entity recognition of news sources, and extraction and topic modeling of quotes. The main news sources were identified by conducting a 1-mode network analysis with SNAnalyzer. The main agendas of nursing-related news coverage were examined through the qualitative analysis of major sources' quotes by section. The common and individual interests of the top-ranked sources were analyzed through a 2-mode network analysis using UCINET.
In total, 128,339 articles from 54 media outlets on nursing-related issues were analyzed. Descriptive analysis showed that nursing-related news was mainly covered in social (99,868/128,339, 77.82%) and local (48,056/128,339, 48.56%) sections, whereas it was rarely covered in economic (9439/128,339, 7.35%) and political (7301/128,339, 5.69%) sections. Furthermore, 445 sources that had made the top 20 list at least once by year and section were analyzed. Other than "nurse," the main sources for each section were "labor union," "local resident," "government," and "Moon Jae-in." "Nursing Bill" emerged as a common interest among nurses and doctors, although the topic did not garner considerable attention from the Ministry of Health and Welfare. Analyzing quotes showed that nurses were portrayed as heroes, laborers, survivors of abuse, and perpetrators. The economic section focused on employment of youth and women in nursing. In the political section, conflicts between nurses and doctors, which may have caused policy confusion, were highlighted. Policy formulation processes were not adequately reported. Media coverage of the enactment of nursing laws tended to relate to confrontations between political parties.
The media plays a crucial role in highlighting various aspects of nursing practice. However, policy formulation processes to solve nursing issues were not adequately reported in South Korea. This study suggests that nurses should secure policy compliance by persuading the public to understand their professional perspectives.
近年来,韩国社会越来越认识到护士在人口老龄化和传染病控制背景下的重要性。然而,护士在旨在改善护理人员队伍结构和工作环境的政策活动方面仍然面临困难。媒体报道在公众对特定问题的认识中发挥着重要作用,是政策活动的重要策略。
本研究分析了 18 年来有关护理问题的新闻报道数据。本研究的重点是通过对主要来源及其引语的分析,考察媒体强调的社会、地方、经济和政治议程的驱动因素。这一分析揭示了哪些护理媒体议程得到了强调(例如,社会方面),哪些被忽视(例如,政策方面),以及哪些被协商。
采用描述性分析、自然语言处理和语义网络分析,对 2005 年至 2022 年期间收集的数据进行分析。使用 BigKinds 进行数据收集、新闻的自动多分类、新闻来源的命名实体识别以及引语的提取和主题建模。使用 SNAnalyzer 进行 1 模式网络分析,确定主要新闻来源。通过对主要来源引语的定性分析,检查护理相关新闻报道的主要议题。使用 UCINET 进行 2 模式网络分析,分析排名前几位的来源的共同和个别利益。
共分析了 54 家媒体关于护理问题的 128339 篇文章。描述性分析显示,护理相关新闻主要在社会(99868/128339,77.82%)和地方(48056/128339,48.56%)部分报道,而在经济(9439/128339,7.35%)和政治(7301/128339,5.69%)部分很少报道。此外,还分析了按年份和部分至少进入前 20 名的 445 个来源。除了“护士”之外,每个部分的主要来源是“工会”、“当地居民”、“政府”和“文在寅”。“护理法案”成为护士和医生的共同利益,尽管该主题并未引起保健福利部的关注。分析引语表明,护士被描绘成英雄、劳动者、虐待幸存者和施虐者。经济部分侧重于青年和妇女在护理方面的就业。在政治部分,突出了护士和医生之间的冲突,这可能导致政策混乱。政策制定过程没有得到充分报道。有关护理法颁布的媒体报道往往与政党之间的对抗有关。
媒体在突出护理实践的各个方面发挥着至关重要的作用。然而,韩国在报道解决护理问题的政策制定过程方面做得还不够。本研究建议护士通过说服公众了解他们的专业观点,来确保政策的遵守。