Jouhet Oriane, Demir Jiyan, Sitbon Marine, Bildan Marc-Antoine, Bros Ariane, Kim Esther, Godron Nicolas, Madelaine Isabelle, Deville Laure
Pharmacie à usage intérieur, hôpital Saint-Louis (Assistance publique-Hôpitaux de Paris), 1, avenue Claude-Vellefaux, 75010 Paris, France.
Pharmacie à usage intérieur, hôpital Saint-Louis (Assistance publique-Hôpitaux de Paris), 1, avenue Claude-Vellefaux, 75010 Paris, France.
Ann Pharm Fr. 2024 Jun;82(4):727-738. doi: 10.1016/j.pharma.2024.02.012. Epub 2024 Feb 24.
The reform of derogatory access authorisations (DAs) on 1st July 2021 has distorted the routine of the hospital pharmacists dealing with innovative medicines that are waiting for marketing authorization or approval. There are two distinct categories of DAs: Compassionate Access Authorisations (CAAs) are granted by the French National Agency for the Safety of Medicines (ANSM) while Early Access Authorisations (EAPs) are granted at the request of pharmaceutical companies by the French National Authority for Health (HAS). All AAPs and a majority of the AACs are supported by a Protocol for Therapeutic Use and Data Collection (PTU-DC). The aim of this study is to assess the impact of the reform on pharmacy process one year following its implementation, and to identify the risks related to the new circuits. The working group, composed of three pharmacists carried out an initial assessment of the effects first measured the impact of the reform on medicine processes in DAs. They performed a comparison of the changes in their management methods: 3 months prior to the reform (M0), and 3 (M3) and 12 months (M12) post-reform. Risks analysis was conducted using the Failure Modes, Effects and Criticality Analysis (FMEA) method. The analysis was limited to the process steps specific related to DAs drugs were analyzed. The critical severity of the risk situations identified was rated. A critical hierarchy matrix was used to establish priority actions. The priority actions to be taken were determined using the critical hierarchy matrix. Over the span of one year, the number of DAs in our establishment showed a 31.7% increase, from 41 at M0 to 54 at M12. At M0, the proportion of drugs needed inclusion via a drug-specific digital platform, specific to each drug, stood at 27% (11/41) of drugs at M0 while at M12, it rose to 52% (28/54). The percentage of PTU-DCs therefore increased by a factor of 1.7, rising from 29% (12/41) at M0 to 47% (21/45) at M3 and 60% (32/54) at M12. For orders, which are always nominative, approval depends on both the presence of the PTU-DC tracking sheet being present in 12% of PAAs, and the inclusion number in 26% of PAAs. The risk analysis shows 49 failure modes leading to risk situations. Among the failure modes, 36 have a consequence of acceptable or tolerable criticality under control, whilst 13 are deemed of unacceptable criticality. A suitable control method exists has been identifies for 5 of them. Finally, the ranking evaluation of criticalities has highlighted 4 situations which require immediate action as a priority: delivery times, obtaining completed tracking sheets and ordering procedures. The aim of the DAs reform is to simplify access to innovative medicines. However, the reform has significant and damaging repercussions on pharmaceutical activities. Corrective measures need to be taken in conjunction with all parties involved in the circuits including laboratories and service providers (CROs), authorities and healthcare professionals.
2021年7月1日对贬损性使用授权(DAs)的改革扰乱了医院药剂师处理等待上市授权或批准的创新药物的日常工作。贬损性使用授权有两种不同类型:同情性使用授权(CAAs)由法国国家药品安全局(ANSM)授予,而早期使用授权(EAPs)则应制药公司的请求由法国国家卫生管理局(HAS)授予。所有的AAPs和大多数的AACs都有治疗使用和数据收集协议(PTU-DC)的支持。本研究的目的是评估改革实施一年后对药房流程的影响,并识别与新流程相关的风险。由三名药剂师组成的工作组首先对改革对DAs中药物流程的影响进行了初步评估。他们对改革前3个月(M0)、改革后3个月(M3)和12个月(M12)的管理方法变化进行了比较。使用失效模式、影响及危害性分析(FMEA)方法进行风险分析。分析仅限于与DAs特定相关的流程步骤,对药物进行了分析。对识别出的风险情况的关键严重性进行了评级。使用关键层次矩阵确定优先行动。通过关键层次矩阵确定了要采取的优先行动。在一年的时间里,我们机构的DAs数量增加了31.7%,从M0时的41个增加到M12时的54个。在M0时,需要通过特定于每种药物的药物专用数字平台纳入的药物比例为M0时药物的27%(11/41),而在M12时,这一比例上升到了52%(28/54)。因此,PTU-DCs的百分比增加了1.7倍,从M0时的29%(12/41)上升到M3时的47%(21/45)和M12时的60%(32/54)。对于总是记名的订单,批准取决于12%的PAA中是否有PTU-DC跟踪表,以及26%的PAA中的纳入编号。风险分析显示有49种失效模式会导致风险情况。在这些失效模式中,36种的后果在可控范围内,临界性可接受或可容忍,而13种被认为具有不可接受的临界性。已经为其中5种确定了合适的控制方法。最后,临界性的排名评估突出了4种需要立即优先采取行动的情况:交货时间、获取完整的跟踪表和订购程序。DAs改革的目的是简化创新药物的获取。然而,改革对制药活动产生了重大且有害的影响。需要与参与流程的所有各方,包括实验室和服务提供商(CROs)、当局和医疗保健专业人员一起采取纠正措施。