Drs Bruno, Tehrani, and Mr Kaufman are affiliated with the Touro College of Osteopathic Medicine, Middletown, New York. Dr Bruno is affiliated with the Department of Public Health, School of Health Sciences and Practice, New York Medical College, Valhalla, New York. Drs Degani-Costa, Tokeshi, and Fidalgo are affiliated with the Department of Psychiatry, Universidade Federal de São Paulo/Escola Paulista de Medicina, São Paulo, Brazil. Drs Degani-Costa and Ms Gushken are affiliated with the Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein - Faculdade Israelita de Ciências da Saúde Albert Einstein, São Paulo, Brazil. Dr Kandipudi is affiliated with the Andhra Medical College, Vishakhapatnam, India. Dr Szlejf is affiliated with the Department of Big Data, Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein, São Paulo, Brazil. Dr Kumar is affiliated with the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Mangalagiri, India. Dr Jamir is affiliated with the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Guwahati, India. Drs Benesch and Ryan are affiliated with Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada. Drs Lotay and Fuld are affiliated with the Department of Respiratory Medicine, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, United Kingdom. Dr Fidalgo is affiliated with the National Academy of Medicine, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Respir Care. 2024 Feb 28;69(3):306-316. doi: 10.4187/respcare.11042.
The rising prevalence of electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) and hookah use among youth raises questions about medical trainees' views of these products. We aimed to investigate medical trainees' knowledge and attitudes toward e-cigarette and hookah use.
We used data from a large cross-sectional survey of medical trainees in Brazil, the United States, and India. We investigated demographic and mental health aspects, history of e-cigarettes and tobacco use, knowledge and attitudes toward e-cigarettes and hookah, and sources of information on e-cigarettes and hookah. Although all medical trainees were eligible for the original study, only senior students and physicians-in-training were included in the present analysis.
Of 2,036 senior students and physicians-in-training, 27.4% believed e-cigarette use to be less harmful than tobacco smoking. As for hookah use, 14.9% believed it posed a lower risk than cigarettes. More than a third of trainees did not acknowledge the risks of passive e-cigarette use (42.9%) or hookah smoking (35.1%). Also, 32.4% endorsed e-cigarettes to quit smoking, whereas 22.5% felt ill equipped to discuss these tobacco products with patients. Fewer than half recalled attending lectures on these topics, and their most common sources of information were social media (54.5%), Google (40.8%), and friends and relatives (40.3%).
Medical trainees often reported incorrect or biased perceptions of e-cigarettes and hookah, resorted to unreliable sources of information, and lacked the confidence to discuss the topic with patients. An expanded curriculum emphasis on e-cigarette and hookah use might be necessary because failing to address these educational gaps could risk years of efforts against smoking normalization.
电子烟和水烟在青少年中的使用日益普及,这引发了人们对医学实习生对这些产品看法的疑问。我们旨在调查医学实习生对电子烟和水烟使用的认识和态度。
我们使用了来自巴西、美国和印度的一项大型医学实习生横断面调查的数据。我们调查了人口统计学和心理健康方面、电子烟和烟草使用史、对电子烟和水烟的认识和态度,以及电子烟和水烟信息来源。尽管所有医学实习生都有资格参加原始研究,但只有高年级学生和实习医生被纳入本分析。
在 2036 名高年级学生和实习医生中,27.4%的人认为电子烟的使用危害小于吸烟。至于水烟的使用,14.9%的人认为它比香烟的风险低。超过三分之一的实习生没有意识到被动电子烟使用(42.9%)或水烟吸烟(35.1%)的风险。此外,32.4%的人支持使用电子烟戒烟,而 22.5%的人觉得自己没有能力与患者讨论这些烟草产品。不到一半的人记得参加过这些主题的讲座,他们最常见的信息来源是社交媒体(54.5%)、谷歌(40.8%)和朋友和亲戚(40.3%)。
医学实习生经常报告对电子烟和水烟的不正确或有偏见的看法,依赖不可靠的信息来源,并且缺乏与患者讨论该主题的信心。扩大课程对电子烟和水烟使用的重视可能是必要的,因为如果不解决这些教育差距,多年来反对吸烟正常化的努力可能会付诸东流。