Int J Gynecol Pathol. 2024 Nov 1;43(6):652-660. doi: 10.1097/PGP.0000000000001022. Epub 2024 Feb 19.
Journal clubs (JCs) are a common format used in teaching institutions to promote trainee engagement and develop skills in seeking out evidence-based medicine and critically evaluating literature. Digital technology has made JC accessible to worldwide audiences, which allows for increased inclusion of globally diverse presenters and attendees. Herein we describe the experience of the first 2 years of a virtual gynecologic pathology JC designed with the goal of providing mentorship and increasing inclusivity. JC began in a virtual format in April 2020 in response to the need for remote learning during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. Each JC had 1 moderator, lasted 1 hour, featured up to 3 trainees/early-career pathologists, and covered articles on gynecologic surgical pathology/cytopathology. Trainees were recruited through direct contact with moderators and advertising through social media (eg, Twitter). A template was used for all presentations, and before presenting, live practice sessions were conducted with the moderator providing constructive feedback and evaluations were provided to presenters and attendees for feedback. Recordings of the meetings were made publicly available after the event through YouTube, a society website, and emails to registrants. Fifty-nine presenters participated, covering 71 articles. Most were trainees (53/59; 89%) from North America (33/59; 56%), with additional presenters from Asia (14/59; 24%), Australia/Oceania (5/59; 8%), Africa (4/59; 7%), and Europe (3/59; 5%). An average of 20 hours were spent per month by moderators on the selection of papers, meeting preparation, and provision of mentorship/feedback. Live events had a total of 827 attendees, and 16,138 interactions with the recordings were noted. Among those who self-identified on provided surveys, the attendees were most commonly from Europe (107/290; 37%) and were overwhelmingly practicing pathologists (275/341; 81%). The experience, including mentorship, format, and content, was positively reviewed by attendees and presenters. Virtual JC is an inclusive educational opportunity to engage trainees and early-career pathologists from around the world. The format allowed for the JC to be widely viewed by attendees from multiple countries, most being practicing pathologists. Based on feedback received, virtual JC appears to expand the medical knowledge of the attendees and empower presenters to develop their expertise and communication skills.
期刊俱乐部(JCs)是教学机构中常用的一种形式,用于促进学员参与,并培养他们寻找循证医学证据和批判性评估文献的能力。数字技术使 JC 能够面向全球受众,从而增加了来自全球各地的多元化演讲者和与会者的参与度。在此,我们描述了一个虚拟妇科病理学 JC 的前 2 年的经验,该 JC 的设计目标是提供指导并提高包容性。JC 于 2020 年 4 月以虚拟形式开始,以满足在 2019 年冠状病毒病大流行期间远程学习的需求。每个 JC 都有 1 名主持人,持续 1 小时,最多有 3 名学员/早期职业病理学家参加,并涵盖妇科手术病理学/细胞学的文章。学员通过与主持人的直接联系和通过社交媒体(例如 Twitter)进行广告招募。所有演示文稿都使用模板进行,在演示之前,与主持人一起进行现场练习,主持人提供建设性反馈,并且向演示者和与会者提供反馈。会议记录在活动结束后通过 YouTube、学会网站和电子邮件向注册者公开。共有 59 名演讲者参加,涵盖了 71 篇文章。大多数是来自北美的学员(53/59;89%)(33/59;56%),还有来自亚洲(14/59;24%)、澳大利亚/大洋洲(5/59;8%)、非洲(4/59;7%)和欧洲(3/59;5%)的演讲者。主持人每月平均花费 20 小时用于选择论文、会议准备和提供指导/反馈。现场活动共有 827 名与会者参加,记录的互动次数为 16138 次。在提供调查的自我认同者中,与会者最常见于欧洲(107/290;37%),绝大多数是执业病理学家(275/341;81%)。与会者和演讲者对这种体验,包括指导、形式和内容,都给予了积极评价。虚拟 JC 是一种具有包容性的教育机会,可以吸引来自世界各地的学员和早期职业病理学家。这种形式允许来自多个国家的与会者广泛观看 JC,其中大多数是执业病理学家。根据收到的反馈,虚拟 JC 似乎扩大了与会者的医学知识,并使演讲者能够发展他们的专业知识和沟通技巧。