Scelo Ghislaine, Zugna Daniela, Popovic Maja, Strandberg-Larsen Katrine, Richiardi Lorenzo
Department of Medical Sciences, University of Turin, CPO-Piemonte, Turin, Italy.
Section of Epidemiology, Department of Public Health, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Front Epidemiol. 2024 Feb 29;4:1335241. doi: 10.3389/fepid.2024.1335241. eCollection 2024.
In the medical domain, substantial effort has been invested in generating internally valid estimates in experimental as well as observational studies, but limited effort has been made in testing generalizability, or external validity. Testing the external validity of scientific findings is nevertheless crucial for the application of knowledge across populations. In particular, transporting estimates obtained from observational studies requires the combination of methods for causal inference and methods to transport the effect estimates in order to minimize biases inherent to observational studies and to account for differences between the study and target populations. In this paper, the conceptual framework and assumptions behind transporting results from a population-based study population to a target population is described in an observational setting. An applied example to life-course epidemiology, where internal validity was constructed for illustrative purposes, is shown by using the targeted maximum likelihood estimator.
在医学领域,人们已投入大量精力在实验研究和观察性研究中生成内部有效的估计值,但在测试可推广性或外部有效性方面所做的工作有限。然而,测试科学发现的外部有效性对于知识在不同人群中的应用至关重要。特别是,将从观察性研究中获得的估计值进行迁移,需要结合因果推断方法和效应估计值迁移方法,以尽量减少观察性研究固有的偏差,并考虑研究人群与目标人群之间的差异。本文在观察性背景下描述了将基于人群的研究结果迁移到目标人群背后的概念框架和假设。通过使用靶向最大似然估计器,给出了一个生命历程流行病学的应用实例,其中为说明目的构建了内部有效性。