Department of Emergency Medicine and Pediatrics (CK Gutman), University of Florida College of Medicine, Gainesville.
Department of Emergency Medicine and Center for Experiential Learning and Simulation (R Fernandez and A McFarlane), University of Florida College of Medicine, Gainesville.
Acad Pediatr. 2024 Aug;24(6):949-956. doi: 10.1016/j.acap.2024.03.002. Epub 2024 Mar 6.
Guidelines for the management of febrile infants emphasize patient-centered communication. Although patient-centeredness is central to high-quality health care, biases may impact physicians' patient-centeredness. We aimed to 1) identify physicians' assumptions that inform their communication with parents of febrile infants and 2) examine physicians' perceptions of bias.
We recruited physicians from 3 academic pediatric emergency departments (EDs) for semistructured interviews. We applied a constant comparative method approach to conduct a thematic analysis of interview transcripts. Two coders followed several analytical steps: 1) discovery of concepts and code assignment, 2) identification of themes by grouping concepts, 3) axial coding to identify thematic properties, and 4) identifying exemplar excerpts for rich description. Thematic saturation was based on repetition, recurrence, and forcefulness.
Fourteen physicians participated. Participants described making assumptions regarding 3 areas: 1) the parent's affect, 2) the parent's social capacity, and 3) the physician's own role in the parent-physician interaction. Thematic properties highlighted the importance of the physician's assumptions in guiding communication and decision-making. Participants acknowledged an awareness of bias and specifically noted that language bias influenced the assumptions that informed their communication.
ED physicians described subjective assumptions about parents that informed their approach to communication when caring for febrile infants. Given the emphasis on patient-centered communication in febrile infant guidelines, future efforts are necessary to understand how assumptions are influenced by biases, the effect of such behaviors on health inequities, and how to combat this.
发热婴儿管理指南强调以患者为中心的沟通。尽管以患者为中心是高质量医疗保健的核心,但偏见可能会影响医生的以患者为中心程度。我们旨在:1)确定医生在与发热婴儿的父母沟通时的假设;2)检查医生对偏见的看法。
我们从 3 家学术儿科急诊部招募了医生进行半结构化访谈。我们采用恒定比较方法对访谈记录进行主题分析。两位编码员遵循了几个分析步骤:1)发现概念和分配代码;2)通过分组概念识别主题;3)轴编码以识别主题属性;4)为了进行详细描述,确定示例摘录。主题饱和度基于重复、重现和说服力。
14 名医生参与了研究。参与者描述了对 3 个领域的假设:1)父母的情绪;2)父母的社会能力;3)医生在医患互动中的角色。主题属性强调了医生假设在指导沟通和决策方面的重要性。参与者承认对偏见的认识,并特别指出语言偏见影响了他们沟通的假设。
ED 医生描述了对父母的主观假设,这些假设指导了他们在照顾发热婴儿时的沟通方法。鉴于发热婴儿指南强调以患者为中心的沟通,未来有必要努力了解假设如何受到偏见的影响、这种行为对健康不平等的影响,以及如何克服这种影响。