Conwell Jordan A
University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Sociol Educ. 2021 Apr;94(2):124-142. doi: 10.1177/0038040720963279. Epub 2021 Mar 19.
In recent decades, the Black-White test score disparity has decreased, while the test score disparity between children of high- versus low-income parents has increased. This study focuses on a comparison that has, to date, fallen between the separate literatures on these diverging trends - Black and White students whose parents have similarly low, middle, or high incomes (i.e., same-income or race-within-income). To do so, I draw on three nationally representative datasets on ninth or tenth graders, covering the period from 1960 to 2009, all of which contain information on students' math test scores. I find that math test score disparities between Black and White students with same-income parents are to Blacks' disadvantage. Although these disparities have decreased since 1960, in 2009, they remain substantively large, statistically significant, and largest between children of the highest income parents. Further, family and school characteristics that scholars commonly use to explain test score disparities by race or by income have accounted for markedly decreasing shares of race-within-income disparities over time. The study integrates the literatures on test score disparities by race and by income with needed attention to race's historical and continued structural influence, net of parental income, on students' educational experiences and test score outcomes.
近几十年来,黑人和白人之间的考试成绩差距有所缩小,而高收入和低收入家庭父母的孩子之间的考试成绩差距却有所扩大。本研究聚焦于一种比较,这种比较在迄今为止关于这些不同趋势的独立文献之间有所缺失——父母收入同样低、中或高的黑人和白人学生(即同收入或收入范围内的种族)。为此,我利用了三个具有全国代表性的关于九年级或十年级学生的数据集,涵盖1960年至2009年期间,所有这些数据集都包含学生数学考试成绩的信息。我发现,父母收入相同的黑人和白人学生之间的数学考试成绩差距对黑人不利。尽管自1960年以来这些差距有所缩小,但在2009年,它们仍然很大,具有统计学意义,并且在收入最高的父母的孩子之间差距最大。此外,学者们通常用来解释按种族或收入划分的考试成绩差距的家庭和学校特征,随着时间的推移,在收入范围内的种族差距中所占的比例显著下降。该研究将关于按种族和收入划分的考试成绩差距的文献整合在一起,同时需要关注种族在扣除父母收入后对学生教育经历和考试成绩结果的历史和持续的结构性影响。