Zgierska Aleksandra E, Gramly Tatum, Prestayko Nicholas, Symons Downs Danielle, Murray Traci M, Yerby Lea G, Howell Brittany, Stahlman Barbara, Cruz Jennifer, Agolli Arjola, Horan Holly, Hilliard Florence, Croff Julie M
Departments of Family and Community Medicine, Anesthesiology and Perioperative Medicine, and Public Health Sciences, Pennsylvania State University College of Medicine, Hershey, PA, USA.
Department of Family and Community Medicine, Pennsylvania State University College of Medicine, Hershey, PA, USA.
J Clin Transl Sci. 2024 Feb 12;8(1):e38. doi: 10.1017/cts.2024.4. eCollection 2024.
Participant recruitment and retention (R&R) are well-documented challenges in longitudinal studies, especially those involving populations historically underrepresented in research and vulnerable groups (e.g., pregnant people or young children and their families), as is the focus of the HEALthy Brain and Child Development (HBCD) birth cohort study. Subpar access to transportation, overnight lodging, childcare, or meals can compromise R&R; yet, guidance on how to overcome these "logistical barriers" is sparse. This study's goal was to learn about the HBCD sites' plans and develop best practice recommendations for the HBCD consortium for addressing these logistical barriers.
The HBCD's workgroups developed a survey asking the HBCD sites about their plans for supporting research-related transportation, lodging, childcare, and meals, and about the presence of institutional policies to guide their approach. Descriptive statistics described the quantitative survey data. Qualitative survey responses were brief, not warranting formal qualitative analysis; their content was summarized.
Twenty-eight respondents, representing unique recruitment locations across the U.S., completed the survey. The results indicated substantial heterogeneity across the respondents in their approach toward supporting research-related transportation, lodging, childcare, and meals. Three respondents were aware of institutional policies guiding research-related transportation (10.7%) or childcare (10.7%).
This study highlighted heterogeneity in approaches and scarcity of institutional policies regarding research-related transportation, lodging, childcare, and meals, underscoring the need for guidance in this area to ensure equitable support of participant R&R across different settings and populations, so that participants are representative of the larger community, and increase research result validity and generalizability.
在纵向研究中,尤其是涉及研究中历史上代表性不足的人群和弱势群体(如孕妇或幼儿及其家庭)的研究,参与者招募与保留是有充分记录的挑战,这也是健康大脑与儿童发育(HBCD)出生队列研究的重点。交通、住宿、儿童保育或餐饮的条件不佳可能会影响招募与保留;然而,关于如何克服这些“后勤障碍”的指导却很少。本研究的目的是了解HBCD各研究点的计划,并为HBCD联盟制定应对这些后勤障碍的最佳实践建议。
HBCD的工作组设计了一项调查,询问HBCD各研究点在支持与研究相关的交通、住宿、儿童保育和餐饮方面的计划,以及是否存在指导其做法的机构政策。描述性统计分析描述了定量调查数据。定性调查回复简短,无需进行正式的定性分析;对其内容进行了总结。
代表美国各地不同招募地点的28名受访者完成了调查。结果表明,受访者在支持与研究相关的交通、住宿、儿童保育和餐饮的方法上存在很大差异。三名受访者知晓指导与研究相关交通(10.7%)或儿童保育(10.7%)的机构政策。
本研究突出了在与研究相关的交通、住宿、儿童保育和餐饮方面方法的异质性以及机构政策的匮乏,强调了在这一领域需要指导以确保在不同环境和人群中公平支持参与者的招募与保留,从而使参与者能够代表更广泛的社区,并提高研究结果的有效性和普遍性。