Elfassy Caroline, Araújo Clarice Ribeiro Soares, Dunn Tessah, Cachecho Sarah, Elekanachi Rose, Higgins Johanne, Snider Laurie, Dahan-Oliel Noemi
Can J Occup Ther. 2024 Dec;91(4):325-373. doi: 10.1177/00084174241233513. Epub 2024 Mar 28.
Performance-based outcome measures (PBOMs) are objective measures that assess physical capacity or performance in specific tasks or movements. 1) to identify which PBOMs are most frequently reported to evaluate upper extremity (UE) function in pediatric rehabilitation 2) to determine the link between constructs of the ICF and meaningful concepts extracted from each identified PBOM. Pediatric UE PBOMs were searched in four databases. The selection of outcome measures included an initial title and abstract screening, followed by full-text review of the articles to be included based on identified selection criteria. Two reviewers were appointed to link the meaningful concepts identified in the outcome measures independently and a third reviewer was consulted in case of ambiguity to make a final decision. After the initial screening, 1786 full-text articles were reviewed, 1191 met the inclusion criteria, in which 77 outcome measures were identified and 32 were included in the linking process. From the included 32 outcome measures, 538 items were extracted and linked to the ICF. The most commonly cited measures included Assisting Hand Assessment, Jebsen-Taylor Hand Function Test, Melbourne Assessment of Unilateral Upper Limb. The Activity and Participation domain represented 364 codes followed by the Body Functions domain domain which represented 174 codes. A majority of the outcome measures identified were linked with the Mobility, Fine Hand Use of the ICF. Therefore, when selecting a PBOM, careful considerations need to be made regarding which concept of health is to be assessed.
基于表现的结果指标(PBOMs)是评估特定任务或动作中的身体能力或表现的客观指标。1)确定在儿科康复中评估上肢(UE)功能时最常报告的PBOMs;2)确定国际功能、残疾和健康分类(ICF)的概念与从每个确定的PBOM中提取的有意义概念之间的联系。在四个数据库中搜索儿科UE PBOMs。结果指标的选择包括初步的标题和摘要筛选,然后根据确定的选择标准对纳入的文章进行全文审查。指定两名审查员独立关联结果指标中确定的有意义概念,如有歧义则咨询第三名审查员以做出最终决定。初步筛选后,审查了1786篇全文文章,1191篇符合纳入标准,其中确定了77项结果指标,32项纳入关联过程。从纳入的32项结果指标中,提取了538项并与ICF进行关联。最常被引用的指标包括辅助手评估、杰布森-泰勒手功能测试、墨尔本单侧上肢评估。活动和参与领域有364个编码,其次是身体功能领域,有174个编码。确定的大多数结果指标与ICF的移动性、精细手部使用相关。因此,在选择PBOM时,需要仔细考虑要评估的健康概念。