Lamb Danielle, Banerjee Rupa, Emanuel Talia
Ted Rogers School of Management, Toronto Metropolitan University, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Can Public Policy. 2022 Oct 1;48(Suppl 1):60-78. doi: 10.3138/cpp.2022-003.
The global coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has exposed and arguably intensified many existing inequalities. This analysis explores the relationship between recent immigrant earnings and the pandemic. Specifically, we attempt to empirically answer the question "Has the COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated (or mitigated) recent immigrant-non-immigrant employment and wage gaps?" We find that the pandemic did not change the labour force activity profile of recent or long-term immigrants. Moreover, the pandemic did not disproportionately disadvantage recent immigrants' earnings. In fact, recent immigrant men who were employed during the COVID-19 crisis experienced a small but statistically significant earnings premium. This was insufficient, however, to overcome the overall earnings discount associated with being a recent immigrant. In addition, we find that the recent immigrant COVID-19 earnings boost is observable only at and below the median of the earnings distribution. We also use Heckman selection correction to attempt to adjust for unobserved sample selection into employment during the pandemic. The fact that COVID-19 has not worsened recent immigrant earnings gaps should not overshadow the large, recent immigrant earnings disparities that existed before the pandemic and continue to exist regardless of the COVID-19 crisis.
全球2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行暴露了许多现有的不平等现象,可以说还加剧了这些不平等。本分析探讨了近期移民收入与大流行之间的关系。具体而言,我们试图通过实证回答“COVID-19大流行是否加剧(或缓解)了近期移民与非移民之间的就业和工资差距?”这一问题。我们发现,大流行并未改变近期或长期移民的劳动力活动概况。此外,大流行并未使近期移民的收入处于不成比例的劣势。事实上,在COVID-19危机期间就业的近期移民男性获得了虽小但在统计上显著的收入溢价。然而,这不足以克服与作为近期移民相关的总体收入折扣。此外,我们发现,近期移民的COVID-19收入增长仅在收入分布中位数及以下可见。我们还使用赫克曼选择校正来尝试调整大流行期间就业中未观察到的样本选择。COVID-19并未加剧近期移民的收入差距这一事实,不应掩盖大流行之前就存在且无论COVID-19危机如何仍继续存在的巨大的近期移民收入差距。