Han Yunmin, Sung Hoyong, Kim Geonhui, Ryu Yeun, Yoon Jiyeon, Kim Yeon Soo
Department of Physical Education, Seoul National University, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Department of Military Kinesiology, Korea Military Academy, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
JMIR Cardio. 2024 Apr 18;8:e42402. doi: 10.2196/42402.
Mediated diet and exercise methods yield effective short-term weight loss but are costly and hard to manage. However, web-based programs can serve many participants, offering ease of access and cost-efficiency.
This study aimed to compare the effectiveness of a web-based weight management program through web-based education alone (MINE) or combined with tailored video feedback (MINE Plus) with a control (CO) group.
This intervention included 60 Korean women with overweight and obesity (BMI≥23 kg/m) aged 19 years to 39 years old. We randomly allocated 60 participants to each of 3 groups: (1) MINE group (web-based education video and self-monitoring app), (2) MINE Plus group (web-based education video, self-monitoring app, and 1:1 tailored video feedback), and (3) CO group (only self-monitoring app). Web-based education included nutrition, physical activity, psychological factors, medical knowledge for weight loss, goal setting, and cognitive and behavioral strategies. Tailored feedback aimed to motivate and provide solutions via weekly 10-minute real-time video sessions. The intervention lasted 6 weeks, followed by a 6-week observation period to assess the education's lasting effects, with evaluations at baseline, 6 weeks, and 12 weeks. A generalized linear mixed model was used to evaluate time and group interactions.
In the intention-to-treat analysis including all 60 participants, there were significant differences in weight change at 6 weeks in the MINE and MINE Plus groups, with mean weight changes of -0.74 (SD 1.96) kg (P=.03) and -1.87 (SD 1.8) kg (P<.001), respectively, while no significant change was observed in the CO group, who had a mean weight increase of 0.03 (SD 1.68) kg (P=.91). After 12 weeks, changes in body weight were -1.65 (SD 2.64) kg in the MINE group, -1.59 (SD 2.79) kg in the MINE Plus group, and 0.43 (SD 1.42) kg in the CO group. There was a significant difference between the MINE and MINE Plus groups (P<.001). Significant group × time effects were found for body weight in the MINE and CO groups (P<.001) and in the MINE Plus and CO groups (P<.001), comparing baseline and 12 weeks. Regarding physical activity and psychological factors, only body shape satisfaction and health self-efficacy were associated with improvements in the MINE and MINE Plus groups (P<.001).
This study found that the group receiving education and tailored feedback showed significant weight loss and improvements in several psychological factors, though there were differences in the sustainability of the effects.
Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency (KDCA) KCT0007780: https://cris.nih.go.kr/cris/search/detailSearch.do/22861.
介导的饮食和运动方法能在短期内有效减轻体重,但成本高昂且难以管理。然而,基于网络的项目可以服务众多参与者,具有易于访问和成本效益高的特点。
本研究旨在比较仅通过基于网络的教育(MINE)或结合量身定制的视频反馈(MINE Plus)的基于网络的体重管理项目与对照组(CO)的效果。
本干预研究纳入了60名年龄在19岁至39岁之间的超重和肥胖(BMI≥23 kg/m²)韩国女性。我们将60名参与者随机分为3组:(1)MINE组(基于网络的教育视频和自我监测应用程序),(2)MINE Plus组(基于网络的教育视频、自我监测应用程序和一对一量身定制的视频反馈),以及(3)CO组(仅自我监测应用程序)。基于网络的教育内容包括营养、体育活动、心理因素、减肥医学知识、目标设定以及认知和行为策略。量身定制的反馈旨在通过每周10分钟的实时视频会议激励参与者并提供解决方案。干预持续6周,随后是6周的观察期,以评估教育的长期效果,在基线、6周和12周进行评估。使用广义线性混合模型来评估时间和组间的相互作用。
在包括所有60名参与者的意向性分析中,MINE组和MINE Plus组在6周时体重变化存在显著差异,平均体重变化分别为-0.74(标准差1.96)kg(P = 0.03)和-1.87(标准差1.8)kg(P < 0.001),而CO组未观察到显著变化,平均体重增加0.03(标准差1.68)kg(P = 0.91)。12周后,MINE组体重变化为-1.65(标准差2.64)kg,MINE Plus组为-1.59(标准差2.79)kg,CO组为0.43(标准差1.42)kg。MINE组和MINE Plus组之间存在显著差异(P < 0.001)。比较基线和12周时,在MINE组和CO组(P < 0.001)以及MINE Plus组和CO组(P < 0.001)中发现了体重的显著组×时间效应。关于体育活动和心理因素,只有身体形状满意度和健康自我效能感与MINE组和MINE Plus组的改善相关(P < 0.001)。
本研究发现,接受教育和量身定制反馈的组体重显著减轻,并且在几个心理因素方面有所改善,尽管效果的可持续性存在差异。
韩国疾病控制与预防机构(KDCA)KCT0007780:https://cris.nih.go.kr/cris/search/detailSearch.do/22861 。