Department of Philosophy, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA.
Wiley Interdiscip Rev Cogn Sci. 2024 Jul-Aug;15(4):e1679. doi: 10.1002/wcs.1679. Epub 2024 Apr 24.
Cognitive science was founded on the idea that the mind/brain can be understood in computational terms. While computational modeling in science is ubiquitous, cognitive science takes the stronger stance that the mind/brain literally performs computations. Moreover, performing computations is crucial to explaining what the mind/brain does, qua mind/brain. Unfortunately, most scientists fail to consider analog computation as a legitimate and theoretically useful type of computation in addition to digital computation; to the extent that analog computation is acknowledged, it is mostly based on a simplistic and incomplete understanding. Taking computation to consist of only one type (i.e., digital) while ignoring another, interestingly distinct type (i.e., analog) leads to an impoverished understanding of what it could mean for minds/brains to compute. A full appreciation and understanding of analog computation-particularly in relation to digital computation-allows researchers to develop computational frameworks and hypotheses in new and exciting ways. Thus, somewhat counterintuitively, looking to the once-dominant computing paradigm of yesteryear can provide novel computational ways of thinking about the mind and brain. This article is categorized under: Philosophy > Foundations of Cognitive Science.
认知科学建立在这样一种理念之上,即心智/大脑可以用计算术语来理解。虽然科学中的计算建模无处不在,但认知科学更加强调心智/大脑实际上执行计算。此外,执行计算对于解释心智/大脑作为心智/大脑所做的事情至关重要。不幸的是,大多数科学家未能将模拟计算视为除数字计算之外另一种合法且具有理论意义的计算类型;在承认模拟计算的程度上,它主要基于一种简单和不完整的理解。将计算仅局限于一种类型(即数字)而忽略另一种有趣而独特的类型(即模拟),会导致对心智/大脑进行计算的含义的理解变得匮乏。全面理解和欣赏模拟计算——特别是与数字计算的关系——可以使研究人员以新的和令人兴奋的方式开发计算框架和假设。因此,有些出人意料的是,回顾过去占主导地位的计算范式,可以为思考心智和大脑提供新颖的计算方式。本文归入以下类别:哲学 > 认知科学基础。