Williamson Clark, Wright Sarah T, Beck Dallaghan Gary L
UNC School of Medicine, Chapel Hill, NC USA.
UNC Health Sciences Library, Chapel Hill, NC USA.
Med Sci Educ. 2024 Feb 14;34(2):491-499. doi: 10.1007/s40670-024-01999-w. eCollection 2024 Apr.
Medical students experience anxiety at higher rates than the general public and many are uniquely affected by additional test anxiety throughout their medical education. Although test anxiety has been studied for decades, little evidence has been published suggesting interventions improve examination performance in medical education. Therefore, we set out to review the current literature to elucidate efforts so far and establish trends in research.
Databases searched included PubMed, EMBASE, PsychINFO, ERIC, SCOPUS, and CINAHL. English language articles published between 2010 and 2021 were loaded into a reference manager to screen out duplicate articles. During the full-text screen and data extraction phase, reference lists were also inspected to identify additional articles for inclusion in the study.
Of 883 studies identified, 860 were excluded resulting in 22 studies for extraction and analysis. First-year ( = 15) and second-year ( = 12) students were primarily tested. Less than 10 included third- or fourth-year students. Self-help and wellness interventions were employed, though interventions ranged from dog therapy to deep breathing techniques to fish oil supplementation. Test anxiety was evaluated using self-report questionnaires, such as the Westside Test Anxiety Scale, Beck Anxiety Inventory, and State-Trait Anxiety Inventory. None of the studies reported improved examination scores.
This review identifies a variety of measurement tools and interventions attempting to mitigate test anxiety. As far as improving examination performance, none of the interventions reported was successful. Further research addressing test anxiety that results in improved medical student academic performance should be conducted and also use established assessment tools.
医学生经历焦虑的比例高于普通大众,并且许多人在整个医学教育过程中受到额外考试焦虑的独特影响。尽管考试焦虑已经被研究了几十年,但几乎没有证据表明干预措施能提高医学教育中的考试成绩。因此,我们着手回顾当前的文献,以阐明迄今为止的研究成果并确立研究趋势。
检索的数据库包括PubMed、EMBASE、PsychINFO、ERIC、SCOPUS和CINAHL。将2010年至2021年发表的英文文章导入参考文献管理软件以筛选出重复文章。在全文筛选和数据提取阶段,还检查了参考文献列表以确定纳入研究的其他文章。
在识别出的883项研究中,排除了860项,最终有22项研究用于提取和分析。主要测试对象是一年级(n = 15)和二年级(n = 12)的学生。不到10项研究纳入了三年级或四年级学生。采用了自助和健康干预措施,尽管干预措施范围从宠物疗法到深呼吸技巧再到补充鱼油。使用自我报告问卷评估考试焦虑,如西区考试焦虑量表、贝克焦虑量表和状态-特质焦虑量表。没有一项研究报告考试成绩有所提高。
本综述确定了多种试图减轻考试焦虑的测量工具和干预措施。就提高考试成绩而言,所报告的干预措施均未成功。应开展进一步研究以解决导致医学生学业成绩提高的考试焦虑问题,并使用既定的评估工具。