Rietmann Felix E
University of Fribourg, Switzerland.
Hist Human Sci. 2024 Apr;37(2):87-116. doi: 10.1177/09526951231187556. Epub 2023 Jul 25.
This article examines cinematographic observational studies of infants conducted by a loosely connected group of female psychologists and physicians in the USA from the 1930s to the 1960s. Largely forgotten today, these practitioners realized detailed and carefully planned research projects about infant behavior in a variety of settings-from the laboratory to the well-baby clinic. Although their studies were in conversation with better-known works, such as John Bowlby's research on attachment and René Spitz's films on institutionalized infants, they differed in a close examination of individual characteristics of babies and a critical attitude toward contemporary notions of 'pathological mothering'. In closely following the work of several researchers, including but not limited to pediatrician Margaret Fries (1898-1987), the clinical psychologist Sibylle Escalona (1915-96) and her team members-child psychiatrist Mary Leitch (1914-?) and avant-garde photographer Ellen Auerbach (1906-2004)-and psychologist Anneliese Korner (1918-2010), I argue that their cinematographic works shed a more nuanced light on the landscape of infant research and child psychiatry in the mid 20th century, and open a way for alternative readings of gender, psychoanalysis, and scientific observation at that time.
本文考察了20世纪30年代至60年代,美国一群联系松散的女性心理学家和医生对婴儿进行的电影观察研究。如今这些研究者大多已被遗忘,但她们开展了关于婴儿在从实验室到健康婴儿诊所等各种环境下行为的详细且精心规划的研究项目。尽管她们的研究与一些更知名的作品,如约翰·鲍尔比的依恋研究以及勒内·施皮茨关于孤儿院婴儿的影片相关,但她们的研究在对婴儿个体特征的细致考察以及对当时“病态育儿”观念的批判态度方面存在差异。通过密切追踪几位研究者的工作,包括但不限于儿科医生玛格丽特·弗里斯(1898 - 1987)、临床心理学家西比尔·埃斯卡洛纳(1915 - 96)及其团队成员——儿童精神病学家玛丽·利奇(1914 - ?)和先锋派摄影师埃伦·奥尔巴赫(1906 - 2004)——以及心理学家安妮莉丝·科尔纳(1918 - 2010),我认为她们的电影作品为20世纪中叶的婴儿研究和儿童精神病学领域带来了更为细致入微的视角,并为当时关于性别、精神分析和科学观察的另类解读开辟了道路。