Panico Lidia, Goisis Alice, Martinson Melissa
Center for Research on Social Inequalities (CRIS), Sciences Po, CNRS, 27, rue Saint-Guillaume, 75337, Paris, Cedex 07, France.
Institut National d'Etudes Démographiques (INED), 9 cours des Humanités, CS 50004, 93322, Aubervilliers, Cedex, France.
SSM Popul Health. 2024 Apr 25;26:101674. doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2024.101674. eCollection 2024 Jun.
Longstanding research has shown strong inequalities in low birthweight by household income. However, most such research has focused on Anglophone countries, while evidence emerging from other developed countries suggest a stronger role of education rather than incomes in creating inequalities at birth. This paper compares gradients in low birthweight by maternal education, as well as explores underlying mechanisms contributing to these gradients, in France, the United States, and the United Kingdom.
Analyses are based on harmonized data from large, nationally-representative samples from France, UK and US. We use regression models and decomposition methods to explore the relative role of several possible mechanisms in producing birthweight inequalities.
Inequalities in low birth weight across maternal education groups were relatively similar in the United States, the United Kingdom and France. However, the individual-level mechanisms producing such inequalities varied substantially across the three countries, with income being most important in the US, pregnancy smoking being most evident in France, and the UK occupying an intermediate position. Differences in the mechanisms producing birth health inequalities mirror differences in the policy environment in the three countries.
While inequalities in health appear from the earliest moments in many countries, our results suggest research on birth health inequalities, and therefore policies, is not easily generalizable across national contexts, and call for more scholarship in uncovering the "whys" of health inequalities in a variety of contexts.
长期研究表明,低出生体重在家庭收入方面存在严重不平等。然而,大多数此类研究集中在英语国家,而其他发达国家出现的证据表明,在造成出生时的不平等方面,教育比收入发挥着更强的作用。本文比较了法国、美国和英国低出生体重在孕产妇教育方面的梯度,并探讨了导致这些梯度的潜在机制。
分析基于来自法国、英国和美国具有全国代表性的大型样本的协调数据。我们使用回归模型和分解方法来探讨几种可能机制在产生出生体重不平等方面的相对作用。
美国、英国和法国孕产妇教育组之间低出生体重的不平等相对相似。然而,导致这种不平等的个体层面机制在这三个国家有很大差异,在美国收入最重要,在法国孕期吸烟最为明显,英国则处于中间位置。产生出生健康不平等的机制差异反映了这三个国家政策环境的差异。
虽然许多国家从最早阶段就出现了健康不平等,但我们的结果表明,关于出生健康不平等的研究以及因此制定的政策,在不同国家背景下不容易推广,并呼吁开展更多学术研究以揭示各种背景下健康不平等的“原因”。